Important challenges for coordination and inter-municipal cooperation in health care services: a Delphi study

Abstract

BackgroundDemographical changes have stimulated a coordination reform in the Norwegian health care sector, creating new working practices and extending coordination within and between primary and hospital care, increasing the need for inter-municipal cooperation (IMC). This study aimed to identify challenges to coordination and IMC in the Norwegian health care sector as a basis for further theorizing and managerial advice in this growing area of research and practice.MethodsA Delphi study of consensus development was used. Experts in coordination and IMC in health care services were selected by the healthcare manager or the councillor in their respective municipalities. In the first round, an expert panel received open-ended questions addressing possible challenges, and their answers were categorized and consolidated as the basis for further validation in the second round. The expert panel members were then asked to point out important statements in the third round, before the most important statements ranked by a majority of the members were rated again in the fourth round, including the option to explain the ratings. The same procedure was used in round five, with the exception that the expert panel members could view the consolidated results of their previous rankings as the basis for a new and final rating. The statements reaching consensus in round five were abstracted and themed.ResultsNineteen experts consented to participate. Nine experts (47%) completed all of the five rounds. Eight statements concerning coordination reached consensus, resulting in four themes covering these challenges: different culture, uneven balance of power, lack of the possibility to communicate electronically, and demanding tasks in relation to resources. Three statements regarding challenges to IMC reached consensus, resulting in following themes: coopetition, complex leadership, and resistance to change.ConclusionsThis study identified several important challenges for coordination and it supports previous research. IMC in health care services deals with challenges other than coordination, and these must be addressed specifically. Our study contributes to extended knowledge of theoretical and practical implications in the field of coordination and IMC in health care sector.

Exploring physicians’ decision-making in hospital readmission processes - a comparative case study

“…Inadequate communication and cooperation in planning of hospital discharges, have also been described by Holen-Rabbersvik et al [ 43 ]. Such problems may result in hospital readmissions if the municipalities are not prepared to receive the discharged patients due to facilities, lack of competence or staffing, equipment or lack of institutional space [ 44 ].…”

Barriers to exchanging healthcare information in inter-municipal healthcare services: a qualitative case study

“…In newly established inter-municipal services, there is no established process and information flow, hence the framework is less applicable. Furthermore, it is well known that management of inter-municipal cooperation is challenging [ 3 , 7 ]. There is a lack of literature focusing on communication and information sharing in inter-municipal healthcare services.…”

Critical issues for employees in inter-municipal health care services: a multiple case study

“…Previous research suggests that direct management, which is based on continuous information flow between practitioners and their governing body, as in a traditional, hierarchical organisational structure, is lacking in horizontal cooperation like IMC [ 40 ]. The complex leadership in inter-municipal cooperation in health care services are found to be challenging [ 41 ]. According to the theory of perceived organisational support (POS), supervisor support is an important antecedent to POS [ 25 ], and hence impacts employee commitment, loyalty and performance [ 23 ].…”

“…In previous studies, autonomy in teamwork has been highlighted as important [ 44 , 45 ] Employees in individual services have reduced possibility to be flexible or adapt the services provided because they lack others with whom to collaborate. Challenging governance and democratic control can be found in inter-municipal cooperation [ 15 , 41 ]. However, how this affects employees, and hence service delivery, has not been determined.…”