Individual-level specialisation and interspecific resource partitioning in bees revealed by pollen DNA metabarcoding

Abstract

It is increasingly recognised that intraspecific variation in traits, such as morphology, behaviour, or diet is both ubiquitous and ecologically important. While many species of predators and herbivores are known to display high levels of between-individual diet variation, there is a lack of studies on pollinators. It is important to fill in this gap because individual-level specialisation of flower-visiting insects is expected to affect their efficiency as pollinators with consequences for plant reproduction. Accordingly, the aim of our study was to quantify the level of individual-level specialisation and foraging preferences, as well as interspecific resource partitioning, across different temporal scales in three co-occurring species of bees of the genus Ceratina (Hymenoptera: Apidae: Xylocopinae), C. chalybea, C. nigrolabiata, and C. cucurbitina. We conducted a field experiment where we provided artificial nesting opportunities for the bees and combined a short-term mark-recapture study with the dissection of the bees' nests to obtain repeated samples from individual foraging females and complete pollen provisions from their nests. Hence, we could study variation of the composition of pollen collected by the bees at different temporal scales. We used DNA metabarcoding based on the ITS2 locus to identify the composition of the pollen samples. We found that the composition of pollen carried on the bodies of female bees and stored in the brood provisions in their nests significantly differed among the three co-occurring species. At the intraspecific level, individual females consistently differed in their level of specialisation and in the composition of pollen carried on their bodies and stored in their nests. Our study thus provides evidence of consistent individual-level specialisation in pollinators across multiple temporal scales. We also demonstrate that higher generalisation at the species level stemmed from larger among-individual variation in diets as observed in other types of consumers, such as predators. Our study thus reveals how specialisation and foraging preferences of bees change from the scale of individual foraging bouts to complete pollen provisions accumulated in their nests over their lifetime. Such multi-scale view of foraging behaviour is necessary to improve our understanding of the functioning of plant-flower visitor communities.

Using DNA Metabarcoding to Identify Floral Visitation by Pollinators

“…The ability to identify an individual's entire pollen assemblage results in the valuable characterisation of interactions at varying hierarchical levels throughout a plant-pollinator community [117]. To date, of the studies that have identified resource partitioning within plant-pollinator networks using DNA metabarcoding, all have found that generalised networks or species are made up of specialised individuals [44,84,115,118]. This presents a promising area of research to further investigate the levels of specialisation and generalisation exhibited by pollinators.…”

Using DNA Metabarcoding to Identify Floral Visitation by Pollinators

“…The ability to identify an individual's entire pollen assemblage results in the valuable characterisation of interactions at varying hierarchical levels throughout a plantpollinator community [104]. To date, of the studies that have identified resource partitioning within plant-pollinator networks using DNA metabarcoding, all have found that generalised networks or species are made up of specialised individuals [39,66,68,105]. This presents a promising area of research to further investigate the levels of specialisation and generalisation exhibited by pollinators.…”