Porous elastomeric polymers have been used in a wide range of applications due to their unique characteristics such as biocompatibility, gas permeability, thermal stability, and hydrophobic and dielectric properties. Poly(dimethyl siloxane) (PDMS), a commercially available elastomer, has also been shown to exhibit specific acoustic properties. However, the materials properties were limited due to a lack of control over the chemistry used to prepare the crosslinked PDMS elastomer. Here, the synthesis of PDMS-based polymerized medium internal phase emulsions (polyMIPEs) with tunable storage shear moduli (G') have been prepared using macromolecular thiol-ene reactions. Storage shear moduli values from ~38 to ~330 kPa were achieved by changing the stoichiometric ratio of the thiol-to ene-functionalized PDMS whereas the porosity of the polyMIPEs was controlled by the volume of aqueous phase used in the emulsion formulation. Very low sound velocities (~40 m/s) through the porous materials were recorded using acoustic characterization. Therefore, this work provides an example of the synthesis of soft polyMIPEs with possible applications as acoustic materials.