Influences on teleconsultation project utilization rates: the role of dominant logic

Abstract

BackgroundThis research analyzes teleconsultation from both a mechanistic and complex adaptive system (CAS) dominant logic in order to further understand the influence of dominant logic on utilization rates of teleconsultation projects. In both dominant logics, the objective of teleconsultation projects is to increase access to and quality of healthcare delivery in a cost efficient manner. A mechanistic dominant logic perceives teleconsultation as closely resembling the traditional service delivery model, while a CAS dominant logic focuses on the system’s emergent behavior of learning resulting from the relationships and interactions of participating healthcare providers.MethodsQualitative case studies of 17 teleconsultation projects that were part of four health sciences center (HSC) based telemedicine networks was utilized. Data were collected at two points in time approximately 10 years apart. Semi-structured interviews of 85 key informants (clinicians, administrators, and IT professionals) involved in teleconsultation projects were the primary data collection method.ResultsThe findings indicated that the emergent behavior of effective and sustainable teleconsultation projects differed significantly from what was anticipated in a mechanistic dominant logic. Teleconsultation projects whose emergent behavior focused on continuous learning enabled remote site generalists to manage and treat more complex cases and healthcare problems on their own without having to refer to HSC specialists for assistance. In teleconsultation projects that continued to be effectively utilized, participant roles evolved and were expanded. Further, technology requirements for teleconsultation projects whose emergent behavior was learning did not need to be terribly sophisticated.ConclusionsWhen a teleconsultation project is designed with a mechanistic dominant logic, it is less likely to be sustained, whereas a teleconsultation project designed with a CAS dominant logic is more likely to be sustained. Consistent with a CAS dominant logic, teleconsultation projects that continued to be utilized involved participants taking on new roles and continuously learning. This continuous learning enabled remote site generalists to better handle the constantly changing nature of the problems faced. A CAS dominant logic provides a theoretical framework which explains why the teleconsultation literature about the role of technology, which is based on a mechanistic dominate logic, does not have adequate explanatory power.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12911-016-0392-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Understanding primary care-oncology relationships within a changing healthcare environment

“…Given that rapid changes in primary care ownership across the U.S. are ongoing, it is important for health systems to encourage team-building between primary care and oncology settings, in addition to strengthening infrastructure for information transfer. Prior studies on relationships between providers, particularly within the context of telemedicine, have supported the need to establish interdependent relationships for optimal team-based care [32–35]. Insight from these case studies contributes to our growing understanding of features of both formal and informal relationships that are important for optimal management of a patient’s journey through the cancer care continuum.…”

Designing a novel hybrid healthcare teleconsultation network: a benchtop study of telepathology in Iran and a systematic review

“…These problems being the case, many approaches have been proposed to reduce patient waiting time as well as possible. One of the most effective solutions is deploying teleconsultation networks [4]. A teleconsultation network is an online platform that connects specialists of a field through a secure network to share patient information [5].…”