Innovative propensity with a fuzzy multicriteria approach

Abstract

Purpose Although R&D plays a crucial role in innovativeness and R&D expenditures is the most widely used tool to measure the level of innovativeness of companies, other variables and inputs may be equally interesting. The purpose of this paper is to define an innovative propensity index (IPI) which considers these variables and allows the identification of those companies which have a higher propensity to implement different types of innovativeness. Design/methodology/approach Taking into account, the different criteria that may be considered in an IPI and that the perception of the relative importance of each criterion is subjective, the use of an innovativeness multicriteria decision methodology has been considered appropriate. In particular, an IPI is built from the weighting of the criteria through FAHP methodology. Data mining techniques are subsequently used to establish a non-supervised ranking (clustering) of a sample of firms, considering their IPI values. Findings The application of an IPI to a sample of 1,639 companies operating in different industrial sectors has helped us to find out that this index is useful for identifying those companies which really show an increased innovative capacity. A comparative analysis by sectors has shown that although there are companies from all sectors with a high innovative propensity, the proportion increases in more technological sectors. Moreover, it has been observed that in companies with higher net personnel expenses and high productivity level the innovative propensity is also higher. Originality/value The criteria used to build the index affects innovativeness individually, but the value of the analysis lies in its multicriteria approach and use of fuzzy logic. The validation of the index in a wide sample of firms is another outstanding aspect of the analysis.

A Multi-Criteria Reference Point Based Approach for Assessing Regional Innovation Performance in Spain

“…In [15,16], a new measure of innovation was proposed to find the link between innovation and productivity in Canadian manufacturing industries. [17] define an innovative propensity index (IPI) of firms using a multi-criteria methodology based on Fuzzy AHP. Furthermore, in [18], an integrated innovativeness index is developed for benchmarking firm innovative performance by applying a recent multi-criteria methodology called Intuitionistic fuzzy-TOPSIS.…”

A fuzzy AHP approach to select suppliers in the Brazilian food supply chain

“…Decision-makers, however, may be uncertain about this comparison. Therefore, the FAHP was developed to help DMs to resolve the vague nature of the alternative selection problem (Ganguly & Guin, 2013;Cobo et al, 2019).…”

An integrated decision-making approach for global supplier selection and order allocation to create an environment-friendly supply chain

“…In this study, the AHP technique is coupled with the fuzzy set theory developed by Zadeh (1965Zadeh ( , 1976 to address the data uncertainty and vagueness problem in decision-makers pairwise comparisons. This study utilized fuzzy triangular numbers to make the calculations easier (Cobo et al, 2019). The main benefit of utilizing FAHP is that it is simple and efficiently manages inadequate data.…”