Integrating Personalized Care Planning into Primary Care: a Multiple-Case Study of Early Adopting Patient-Centered Medical Homes

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Personalized care planning is a patientcentered, whole-person approach to treatment planning. Personalized care plans improve patient outcomes and are now mandated for chronic care management reimbursement. Yet guidance on how to best implement personalized care planning in practice is limited. OBJECTIVE: We examined the adoption of personalized care planning in patient-centered medical home (PCMH) clinics to identify processes and organizational characteristics that facilitated or hindered use in routine practice. DESIGN: Qualitative multiple-case study design. We conducted site visits at PCMH clinics in four US Veterans Health Administration (VHA) medical centers. Data included 10 general clinic observations, 34 direct observations of patient-provider clinical encounters, 60 key informant interviews, and a document review. Data were analyzed via qualitative content analysis using a priori and emergent coding. PARTICIPANTS: Employees and patients participating in clinical encounters in PCMH clinics at four VHA medical centers. KEY RESULTS: Each clinic used a distinct approach to personalized care planning: (1) distributed tasks approach; (2) two-tiered approach; (3) health coaching approach; and (4) leveraging a village approach. Each varied in workflow, healthcare team utilization, and degree of integration into clinical care. Across sites, critical components for implementation included expanding planning beyond initial assessment of patient priorities; framing the initiative for patients; using a team-based approach to care plan development and updates; using communication mechanisms beyond the electronic health record; and engaging stakeholders in implementation planning. CONCLUSIONS:Personalized care planning is a novel patient-centered practice, but complicated to implement. We found variation in effective implementation and identified critical components to structuring this practice in a manner that engages patients in treatment aligned with personal priorities. Primary care practices seeking to implement personalized care planning must go beyond simply asking patients a series of questions to establish a plan. They must also engage team members in plan development, communication, and dissemination.

Health Complexity Assessment in Primary Care: a validity and feasibility study of the INTERMED tool

“…INTERMED could enable this approach once its predictive validity and feasibility from PHC teams’ perspective is confirmed. In fact, RCTs and implementation efforts to successfully deliver such a care planning in PHC have recently been conducted(71–73) or are under development(74), including one RCT that used the INTERMED tool (35)…”

Liver Transplant Recipient, Caregiver, and Provider Perceptions of Cardiovascular Disease and Related Risk Factors After Transplant

“…Personalized care planning, used often with medically complex patients, may be a potential system-based solution to improving CVD outcomes in LTRs. (20) Finally, the multidisciplinary nature and complexity of the LTR care teams were reported as significant barriers to appropriate CVD care. LTRs noted that, because of their complex health care needs, they usually have multiple providers, but that they themselves do not know the role of each provider.…”

Factors affecting revisit intention for medical services at dental clinics

“…In the existing disease-centered model, all decisions on patient care are made based on the expertise of doctors and other medical personnel. However, in the patient-centered model, patients actively participate in their treatment process and their needs and preferences are reflected in care-related decision making [ 1 , 2 ]. These changes in the decision-making structure of medical services create competition among medical institutions, forcing them to take steps to survive financially.…”