Interrogating data justice on Hyderabad’s urban frontier: information politics and the internal differentiation of vulnerable communities

Abstract

How does data visibility affect vulnerable communities that face uncertainty over land tenure? Can data justice be realised in settings of acute resource injustice? These are the overarching questions that our case study interrogates by opening up the black box of the community in the volatile and fast-transforming peri-urban fringe of Hyderabad, India. We examine the unfolding of data and information processes through the lens of enumeration and community mapping exercises conducted in a low-income neighbourhood. We argue that the realisation of data justice is mediated by 'information politics', i.e., the ways in which informational resources, as well as the risks and rewards associated with them, are distributed across individual actors and identity groups within the community. The democratizing potential of emerging digital technologies is severely constrained by structural inequities across gender, caste, class, and even linguistic lines. Our case study underlines the importance of such a structural understanding of data justice and also suggests directions for embedding justice in data processes. Our findings reveal an arena of stark informational disparities between vulnerable, indigent populations and the increasingly sophisticated digital data apparatuses used to encode them. Efforts to promote data justice must take explicit cognisance of these disparities and fragmentation and recognise the internal structural differentiation of vulnerable communities. We argue for an explicit mapping of the information flows and associated information politics that characterise such settings.

Towards the platformisation of employment in post-pandemic Aotearoa New Zealand? Evidence from the Future Worlds of Work survey

“…For frontline workers, artificial intelligence and platform technology has been negatively impacting working conditions for some time (Howe et al, 2019;Kennedy et al, 2022). Frontline workers are defined by Blau et al (2021) as a particular subset of essential workers.…”

The Speculative Frontier: Real Estate, Governance and Occupancy on the Metropolitan Periphery

“…With the meteoric rise of real estate values in this area, occupation rights for the most vulnerable communities in the mass of villages incorporated into the municipal corporation in this vicinity-Nanakramguda, Gopanapalli, Gopanapalli Thanda, Gachibowli-have proved precarious (see Kennedy et al 2020).…”

“…is a question to which the answer remains obscure, allowing state actors considerable power without accountability. Channels for collective action or political mobilization by poor groups may be curbed by hazy jurisdictional boundaries and the information gaps they produce, as Kennedy et al (2020) show.…”

Urban studies in India across the millennial turn: Histories and futures

“…The case of Jamshedpur, an early 20th-century company town in eastern India, illustrates patterns of haphazard and under-provisioned growth fostered by such enclave-led urban development, both through exclusions built into planning and enclave-focused modes of infrastructure provision and governance. The neoliberal state, continuing and intensifying this tendency, has fostered informal growth through sheer neglect and oversight (Kennedy and Sood, 2016; Kennedy et al, 2020). What is more, this literature shows how the participatory rhetoric of middle-class associations shapes these exclusions through a variety of governance instruments, such as development authorities, notified area committees and state-level ‘local authorities’ that scaffold such regimes of exception (Sood, 2021; Sood and Kennedy, 2020).…”