“…In addition, the time of the daily peak of the whistler rate at Dunedin is in disagreement with the peak of lightning activity at the conjugate point (Rodger, Lichtenberger, et al, ). The results of Collier et al () suggest tropical Mexico, over 7,000 km from the conjugate point, as the source region, which, however, seem to contradict our understanding of the fundamental physics and also other observations (Antel et al, ; Morgan & Allcock, ).…”