Learning from learning logs: A case study of metacognition in the primary school classroom

Abstract

Structured thinking activities (STAs) are pedagogical tools used to support metacognition in classrooms. Despite their popularity, little is known about how pupils use STAs as platforms to think about and manage their own thinking (i.e. as metacognitive tools). This case study investigated pupils’ use of STAs in relation to metacognition throughout a school year. We focus on two 8‐year‐old pupils, Amy and Laura, as they completed two specific STAs through weekly class meets and termly achievement logs. Data were triangulated through participant observation, qualitative interviews and analysis of written texts. We found clear differences between Laura's and Amy's written STAs, however observation and interviews revealed that engagement with STAs was similar beyond that suggested by the written evidence alone. Whereas Amy used easily spelt ‘stock’ responses, Laura used ‘bare minimum’ responses to meet teacher expectations. As such, neither Amy nor Laura used STAs as metacognitive tools, however in negotiating STAs, both exhibited strategic regulatory skills indicative of metacognition. Whilst our findings highlight that pupils may still be developing explicit metacognitive knowledge necessary to take full advantage of STAs, we highlight the clear value of persistent approaches to using STAs as tools to support developing metacognition, particularly in association with teacher–pupil interactions.

Teachers’ emotions in the time of COVID: Thematic analysis of interview data reveals drivers of professional agency

“…We are optimistic about opportunities and outcomes arising from greater focus on emotions, particularly in teachers’ effective modeling of emotion percepts and associated behaviors for students in the same way that they model meta-cognitive abilities (cf. Branigan and Donaldson, 2019 , 2020 ). Partnerships between psychology and education practitioner-researchers should also encourage more nuanced development and adoption of research findings in education settings ( Immordino-Yang, 2016 ), particularly exploring the impact and limitations of awareness of emotion percepts on pedagogical practices through collection and analysis of rich, robust data ( Newton and Salvi, 2020 ).…”

Multilingual, bilingual, and monolingual Arabic teachers’ development of learner self‐regulation and language awareness in the Emirates

“…In language acquisition contexts, metacognitive strategies and learner autonomy can be subsumed under the concept of self‐regulated learning (see Tsuda & Nakata, 2013), which is an individual's ability and agency to self‐manage and direct their learning through a set of practices and strategies that enhances learning outcomes and sustains their motivation (Schunk & Zimmerman, 2008). Metacognitive strategies, which are a specific category of learning strategies, refer to individuals’ conscious decision to monitor and assess their learning according to their evolving needs and goals, for example, through the use of progress logs and language diaries (Branigan & Donaldson, 2019; Khaldieh, 2000). Learner autonomy can be described as a set of independent practices, and some would say a state of mind, whereby individuals take responsibility for their learning, for instance, by doing additional research at the library on the content covered during lessons (Borg & Alshumaimeri, 2019).…”

The use of Instrumental Enrichment as a method to teach the analysis of the population pyramid to Grade 7 Geography students.

“…This makes thinking procedures automatic and ensures that students develop an awareness of the deep structure of problems. When faced with a new problem, students can solve it by recognising its deep structure and apply the thinking procedures that they have already learnt (Costa, 1991;Branigan & Kanevski, 2018).…”