Limited evidence for extensive genetic differentiation between X and Y chromosomes in Hybognathus amarus (Cypriniformes: Leuciscidae)

Abstract

Sex determination systems and genetic sex differentiation across fishes are highly diverse but are unknown for most Cypriniformes, including Rio Grande silvery minnow (Hybognathus amarus). In this study, we aimed to detect and validate sex-linked markers to infer sex determination system and to demonstrate the utility of combining several methods for sex-linked marker detection in non-model organisms. To identify potential sex-linked markers, Nextera-tagmented reductively-amplified DNA (nextRAD) libraries were generated from 66 females, 64 males and 60 larvae of unknown sex. These data were combined with female and male de novo genomes from Nanopore long read sequences. We identified five potential unique male nextRAD-tags and one potential unique male contig, suggesting an XY sex determination system. We also identified two SNPs in the same contig with values of FST, allele frequencies and heterozygosity conforming with expectations of an XY system. Through PCR we validated the marker containing the sex-linked SNPS and a single nextRAD-tag sex-associated marker but it was not male-specific. Instead, more copies of this locus in the male genome were suggested by enhanced amplification in males. Results are consistent with an XY system with low differentiation between sex determining regions. Further research is needed to confirm the level of differentiation between the sex chromosomes. Nonetheless, this study highlighted the power of combining reduced-representation and whole-genome sequencing for identifying sex-linked markers, especially when reduced representation sequencing does not include extensive variation between sexes, either because such variation is not present or not captured.