Locating Zhuhai between land and sea: a relational production of Zhuhai, China, as an island city

Abstract

ABSTRACT:Despite an abundance of representations that focalize Zhuhai's island and coastal features in both academic and popular discourses, serious engagement with the lived sociogeographic realities of the 'city of a hundred islands' are few and far between. As a critical reaction, this paper seeks a relational production of Zhuhai, China as an island city with specific urban island spatiality. The focus/locus problematic is deployed within the wider context of the relational turn in island studies. First, representations that bring Zhuhai's islandness into focus are categorized and analyzed. It is questioned whether these discourses have constructed for the city an organic collective self that identifies with island and marine values. In an effort to de-focus Zhuhai's island and coastal geographies and re-produce them as locus, a series of place-specific relational issues pertinent to urban island studies are addressed, such as the relationship between island spatiality and city formation, land-sea configurations, and the nature of urban public space between land and sea. It is argued that the island city of Zhuhai's imaginaries and the concretization of its island and coastal possibilities follow a trajectory that is island conscious and mainland unconscious. To propose alternative theoretical models for a more nuanced understanding of the lived realities of the island city of Zhuhai and island cities in general, the paper concludes by re-contextualizing the focus/locus dichotomy within the wider theoretical framework of the relational turn in island studies.

Marginalisation of the Dan fishing community and relocation of Sanya fishing port, Hainan Island, China

“…The repurposing of city centre waterfronts into tourism and leisure zones is a common phenomenon, both elsewhere in China (e.g. 陈永锭, 2013;Hong, 2017) and abroad, but the effects of this displacement of existing urban functions may be particularly strong in island cities in which urban expansion into the interior is difficult.…”

Sacred islands and island symbolism in Ancient and Imperial China: an exercise in decolonial island studies

“…At this time, most of the population of what we now regard as China resided in the north of the country, far from the ocean and sea, and, for most of the next 3500 years, China's centres of political and economic power were located in the continental interior. As a result, China developed a mainland-centred culture (Hong, 2017), and Chinese social, political, and religious actors tended to focus on land power.…”

“…The tension between island as metaphor and island as place has thus formed the crux of much powerful island studies theorisation, engaged in from different perspectives and arriving at different conclusions (e.g., Fletcher, 2011;Ronström, 2013;Pigou-Dennis & Grydehøj, 2014;Hong, 2017).…”

A future of island studies

“…Hayward's warning is an important one, and Shima has indeed helped advance new conceptualisations of the appropriate subject matters and borders of island studies, particularly through development of the 'aquapelago' as a theoretical framework focusing on human-land-sea interaction (launched in Hayward, 2012a; with subsequent contributions from, for example, Hayward, 2012b;Fleury, 2013;Alexander, 2015;Dick, 2015;MacKinnon, 2016;Bremner, 2017). In recent years, I have ventured outside my own scholarly comfort zone of remote, cold-water islands to help establish a distinctive form of urban island studies, which has not only brought new disciplinary perspectives (architecture, urban studies, urban planning) to bear on traditional island studies questions but has also highlighted hitherto under-appreciated connections between islands and cities as well as called into question certain assumptions about the nature of islandness in general (e.g., Grydehøj, 2015;Steyn, 2015;Hayward, 2015;Casagrande, 2016;Grydehøj & Kelman, 2016;Gang, 2017).…”