Long Term Effectiveness on Prescribing of Two Multifaceted Educational Interventions: Results of Two Large Scale Randomized Cluster Trials

Abstract

IntroductionInformation on benefits and risks of drugs is a key element affecting doctors’ prescribing decisions. Outreach visits promoting independent information have proved moderately effective in changing prescribing behaviours.ObjectivesTesting the short and long-term effectiveness on general practitioners’ prescribing of small groups meetings led by pharmacists.MethodsTwo cluster open randomised controlled trials (RCTs) were carried out in a large scale NHS setting. Ad hoc prepared evidence based material were used considering a therapeutic area approach - TEA, with information materials on osteoporosis or prostatic hyperplasia - and a single drug oriented approach - SIDRO, with information materials on me-too drugs of 2 different classes: barnidipine or prulifloxacin. In each study, all 115 Primary Care Groups in a Northern Italy area (2.2 million inhabitants, 1737 general practitioners) were randomised to educational small groups meetings, in which available evidence was provided together with drug utilization data and clinical scenarios. Main outcomes were changes in the six-months prescription of targeted drugs. Longer term results (24 and 48 months) were also evaluated.ResultsIn the TEA trial, one of the four primary outcomes showed a reduction (prescription of alfuzosin compared to tamsulosin and terazosin in benign prostatic hyperplasia: prescribing ratio −8.5%, p = 0.03). Another primary outcome (prescription of risedronate) showed a reduction at 24 and 48 months (−7.6%, p = 0.02; and −9,8%, p = 0.03), but not at six months (−5.1%, p = 0.36). In the SIDRO trial both primary outcomes showed a statistically significant reduction (prescription of barnidipine −9.8%, p = 0.02; prescription of prulifloxacin −11.1%, p = 0.04), which persisted or increased over time.InterpretationThese two cluster RCTs showed the large scale feasibility of a complex educational program in a NHS setting, and its potentially relevant long-term impact on prescribing habits, in particular when focusing on a single drug. National Health systems should invest in independent drug information programs.Trial RegistrationControlled-Trials.com ISRCTN05866587

The use of external change agents to promote quality improvement and organizational change in healthcare organizations: a systematic review

“…Others investigated three or more components. Sixteen studies out of the 21 included in this review used academic detailing (AD) as part of a multi-component intervention strategy [ 10 , 13 , 17 , 21 , 23 – 34 ]. Thirteen studies had a form of audit and feedback integrated into their intervention [ 17 – 19 , 22 – 25 , 28 , 29 , 32 – 35 ].…”

“…Because the context of each study varied and there was not a uniform reporting measure of effect size, we measured the effectiveness of an intervention based on the p values of change between study arms reported in each study. Thirteen of the 21 studies reported a significant positive change ( p < .05) in their primary outcomes on the intervention arm [ 17 – 20 , 22 , 23 , 25 , 27 – 29 , 32 , 34 , 35 ]. All of these studies investigated the effects of multi-faceted interventions that included at least two of the intervention categories described under the data analysis section.…”

“…Academic detailing -the proportion of patients achieving cholesterol targets Intervention patients were significantly more likely to have cholesterol at target (69.5% vs 63.5%; OR 1.11, CI 1.00–1.23; p = 0.043) as a result of improved simvastatin prescribing. Magrini et al, 2014 [ 23 ] Italy Two separate Cluster RCTs: TEA vs SIDRO—115 PC groups in both studies (clinic size NA) pharmacist Intervention: Facilitator has biannual 3–4 h. meetings with audit & feedback and problem-based learning In both TEA and SIDRO trials, 57 primary care groups in arm 1 (TEA: benign prostatic hyperplasia; SIDRO: prulfloxacin) and 58 in arm 2 (TEA: osteoporosis; SIDRO: basmidapine) 1. Academic detailing (biannual 3–4 h meetings) 2.…”

Designing a National Veterinary Prescribing Champion Programme for Welsh Veterinary Practices: The Arwain Vet Cymru Project

“…Educational interventions have been shown to improve knowledge of pharmacovigilance (50) and prescribing competency (51) as well as to strengthen AMS (52)(53)(54), although the effects may be short-lived. Online learning as part of AMS programmes has been playing an increasing role (55) and online training of GPs has been shown to reduce antimicrobial prescribing for respiratory disease (56).…”

A cluster randomized trial to measure the impact on nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug and proton pump inhibitor prescribing in Italy of distributing cost-free paracetamol to osteoarthritic patients

“…Only a few studies have showed effective interventions to modify prescribing habits [18, 19], in particular for NSAIDs [20]. A few other studies have tried to evaluate the efficacy of removing economic barriers to appropriate drug prescribing, but not specifically regarding paracetamol [12, 21].…”