Making war and peace with emotion: Examining the Iraq and Iran cases via presidential speech and media coverage

Abstract

This study investigates emotions conveyed in US presidential speeches and media coverage regarding the Iraq War and the Iran nuclear deal during 2003 and 2015. The researchers gathered and examined news stories about the two policies, all official speeches delivered by George W Bush and Barack Obama, and opinion polls conducted during the respective six-month period in those two years. Nine discrete emotions were coded to capture the valence and volume in the speeches and news media content. The study finds that emotions appear more frequently in the Iraq discourse than in the Iran counterpart. President Bush used more negative emotions while President Obama employed more positive emotions. Emotion in the media coverage is constant and stable across the two policy periods; yet negative emotions are more prevalent than positive counterparts in the media despite distinct foreign policies. The study also examines public opinion trends toward the two policies for inferring potential linkage. This article contributes to the conceptual nexus among emotional persuasion, journalism pattern, and foreign policy-making process.

Online Public Rumor Engagement Model and Intervention Strategy in Major Public Health Emergencies: From the Perspective of Social Psychological Stress

“…In terms of rumor engagement, a large number of researchers have tried to explain why the public is spontaneously engaged in rumor in the public opinion field and why it is engaged in different intensities from the aspects of information dissemination [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ], emotional rendering [ 23 , 24 , 25 ], driving motivation [ 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ], and have made some progress. However, the investigation on the coupling mechanism between the transition of public psychosocial stress state and rumor engagement is slightly insufficient [ 9 ].…”

The Presidential Speeches and the US-Iran Nuclear Deal: Franklin D. Roosevelt and John F. Kennedy Percepts on Freedom, Dignity and Independence

“…Past failed Obama and zealous' Trump administrations only confirmed limited nuclear deal options and negative peace if Biden opted for more restrained sanctions against the Iranian nuclear deal (Lewicka and Dahl 2021;Mearsheimer 2017;Mount 2022;Cavari 2022). It will be argued that in times of trouble, the American precepts of freedom, dignity, and independence (as rhetorically preached by Roosevelt and Kennedy) should be the immediate reference of inspiration for the US to embrace and consider an alternative and more harmonious framework when dealing with differences and resilient of Iran (see also Crist 2018;Seaton and Dennis Wu 2021).…”

President’s speech portrait

“…The main function of a speech portrait is to form a holistic personality image. In political communication, the speech portrait of the linguistic personality is characterized by its peculiarities and is mainly formed by a conscious choice of verbal (linguistic) means [3,4]. It should be mentioned that the outcome and the effectiveness of political communication directly depend on the language personality, the speaker's choice and usage of a set of verbal and non-verbal means of speech influence on the audience.…”