Mapping poverty in rural China: how much does the environment matter?

Abstract

In this paper, we apply a recently developed small-area estimation technique to derive geographically detailed estimates of consumption-based poverty and inequality in rural Shaanxi, China. We also investigate whether using environmental variables derived mainly from satellite remote sensing improves upon traditional approaches that only use household survey and census data. According to our results, ignoring environmental variables in statistical analyses that predict small-area poverty rates leads to targeting errors. In other words, using environmental variables both helps more accurately identify poor areas (so they should be able to receive more transfers of poor area funds) and identify non-poor areas (which would allow policy makers to reduce poverty funds in these better off areas and redirect them to poor areas). Using area-based targeting may be an efficient way to reach the poor since many counties and townships in rural Shaanxi have low levels of inequality, even though, on average, there is more within-group than between-group inequality. Using information on locations that are, in fact, receiving poverty assistance, our analysis also produces evidence that official poverty policy in Shaanxi targets particular areas which in reality are no poorer than other areas that do not get targeted. KeywordsChina environment poverty small area estimation JEL Classification O15, O53, P36, Q56 AcknowledgementsWe are grateful to

Household vulnerability on the frontline of climate change: the Pacific atoll nation of Tuvalu

“…It is unlikely that explanatory variables are readily available to capture these types of latent influences". 18 See Anselin (1988), Elhorst (2014), Gibson and McKenzie (2007), Gibson and Rozelle (2002), Ravallion (1998, 2002), LeSage andPace (2009), andOlivia et al (2011).…”

“…Their work suggests that distance from households to numerous geographic features like roads, markets, schools, and health clinics might be important in understanding poverty. Olivia et al (2011) also outlined the importance of identifying environmental factors that influence poverty. Theoretical links are discussed in World Bank (2007) while Ravallion (1998, 2002) provide empirical evidence linking the poor to geographical variables.…”

Spatial restructuring through poverty alleviation resettlement in rural China

“…Recent estimates indicate that approximately 147e196 million rural Chinese still live below the USD 1.25 per day poverty threshold . Most of these people live on remote, isolated, and marginal lands in western and central China (Olivia et al, 2011). In an effort to eradicate stubborn poverty in the most remote and marginal areas of the country, the Chinese government turned to resettlement.…”

Spatial covariance of ecosystem services and poverty in China

“…Again, this is not a surprising finding, as income rural poverty is a multifaceted issue that is driven by many factors that we were unable to quantify in this study. These include not only access to markets and remittances from migrants to urban areas (Donaldson 2011), demographics and education (Imai and You 2014), income from sources other than natural resources (De Janvry et al 2005) but also biophysical factors such as rainfall and elevation (Olivia et al 2011). …”