Modelling spatio-temporal patterns of disease for spatially misaligned data: An application on measles incidence data in Namibia from 2005-2014

Abstract

BackgroundMaking inferences about measles distribution patterns at small area level is vital for more focal targeted intervention. However, in statistical literature, the analysis of originally collected data on one resolution with the purpose to make inferences on a different level of spatial resolution is referred to as the misalignment problem. In Namibia the measles data were available in aggregated format at regional level for the period 2005 to 2014. This leads to a spatial misalignment problem if the purpose is to make decisions at constituency level. Moreover, although data on risk covariates of measles could be obtained at constituency level, they were not available each year between 2005 and 2014. Thus, assuming that covariates were constant through the study period would induce measurement errors which might have effects on the analysis results. This paper presents a spatio-temporal model through a multi-step approach in order to deal with misalignment and measurement error.MethodsFor the period 2005–2014, measles data from the Ministry of Health and Social Services (MoHSS) were analysed in two steps. First, a multi-step approach was applied to correct spatial misalignment in the data. Second, a classical measurement error model was fitted to account for measurement errors. The time effects were specified using a nonparametric formulation for the linear trend through first order random walk. An interaction between area and time was modelled through type I and type II interaction structures.ResultsThe study showed that there was high variation in measles risk across constituencies and as well as over the study period (2005–2014). Furthermore, the risk of measles was found to be associated with (i) the number of people aged between 0 and 24 years, (ii) the percentages of women aged 15–49 with an educational level more than secondary, (iii) the percentages of children age 12–23 months who received measles vaccine, (iv) the percentages of malnourished children under 5 years, and (vi) the measles cases for each previous year.ConclusionThe study showed some of the determinants of measles risk and revealed areas at high risk through disease mapping. Additionally, the study showed a non-linear temporal distribution of measles risk over the study period. Finally, it was shown that ignoring the measurement errors may yield misleading results. It was recommended that group and geographically targeted intervention, prevention and control strategies can be tailored on the basis these findings.

Wh-Movement, Islands, and Resumption in L1 and L2 Spanish: Is (Un)Grammaticality the Relevant Property?

“…One of the reasons for choosing a timed GJT was to get the first, less conscious intuition about the structure. This would go with a generative view of language, which considers that real time construction of grammar sometimes loses grammar accuracy (Chomsky and Lasnik, 1993;Townsend and Bever, 2001), and against a view in which real-time processing can capture fine-grained distinctions (Phillips, 2003(Phillips, , 2006. In fact, this is not the only experiment which has failed to discover island sensitivity in processing experiments.…”

Identifying Spatiotemporal Clusters by Means of Agglomerative Hierarchical Clustering and Bayesian Regression Analysis with Spatiotemporally Varying Coefficients: Methodology and Application to Dengue Disease in Bandung, Indonesia

“…Similarly, monitoring of socioeconomic risk factors might have been conducted too infrequently. Such circumstances tend to cause measurement errors (Ntirampeba, Neema, and Kazembe 2018). Another problem is that some risk factors such as humidity, precipitation, and temperature tend to be strongly correlated (Wheeler and Tiefelsdorf 2005).…”

Determinants of subnational disparities in antenatal care utilisation: a spatial analysis of demographic and health survey data in Kenya

“…Lack of data powered to provide precise and reliable estimates at units of decision-making hinders the description of the subnational heterogeneities [ 12 ]. Recent advancement in mapping and statistical techniques have allowed mapping of child survival and its determinants at a fine spatial resolution [ 13 – 16 ]. However, the variation of ANC utilisation and its predictors at lower geographical units of decision making remains imperfectly described in Kenya to facilitate policy formulation and targeted interventions [ 17 ].…”