Moving on From the Delphi Study: The Development of a Physical Activity Training Programme Prototype Through Co-produced Qualitative Research

Abstract

This research developed from a co-produced project called Moving Social Work. The purpose of this ongoing project is to train social workers in how to promote physical activity for and to disabled people. The first stage of the project consisted of building evidence to design a training programme prototype. As part of this stage, a Delphi study was conducted to ask leading experts about what should be included in the prototype. Questionnaires were sent to participants until consensus was reached. In reflecting on the results, people involved in the study commented that there was more about the experts’ opinions than percentages of agreement. Our co-production partners resolved that the Delphi was insufficient and called for detailed conversations with the experts. In response to this call, follow-up interviews with 10 experts who participated in the final questionnaire round of the Delphi were carried out. The interviews were co-produced, dyadic and data prompted. Dialogical inquiry was used to frame and co-analyse data. The results illuminate the capacity of qualitative research to justify, rectify, complicate, clarify, concretize, expand and question consensus-based evidence. The implications of the results for Moving Social Work are discussed. Beyond the empirical border of the project, wider contributions to literature are presented. As part of these, two key statements are highlighted and warranted: dialogical inquiry supports the practice of co-produced research, and Delphi studies should be followed by a Big Q qualitative study.

Codesign and Launch of ‘On the Ball’: An Inclusive Community‐Based ‘Testicular Awareness’ Campaign

“…The full study process and timelines are summarised in Figure 1. This study was guided by the WC design principles [23–25]. It received ethical approval from the Social Research Ethics Committee at University College Cork (Log 2022‐227).…”

Improving consensus-based evidence from Delphi studies with coproduced qualitative research

“…‘Moving Social Work (MSW)’ is an UK-based project aiming to codesign structured training and education programmes for social workers to promote PA among PLWD 2. The authors conducted a Delphi study to identify the contents of the training programme prototype.…”

A Delphi Study of Expert Consensus on Chinese Medicine Syndrome Differentiation and Herbal Use for Early Breast Cancer

“… 6 , 9 This study reports the conduct and findings of the expert survey. The Delphi method has been widely used to gain consensus in health research, 10 - 13 including for CM syndromes in breast cancer. Delphi studies by Guan 14 and Guo 15 focussed on the different treatment stages in early breast cancer, and the latter involved the same experts in each of the different rounds.…”