We explored the differential expression and diagnostic value of two significant Mucin 5AC (MUC5AC) glycoforms, less-glycosylated immature (IM) and heavily-glycosylated mature (MM), in neoplastic diseases (NpD), including pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDA) and neuroendocrine tumors (NET), and non-neoplastic (non-NpD) diseases. Commercially available tissue microarray (TMA) was constructed from 96 patients, including 38 primary PDA (PT), 5 metastatic lesions (ML), 11 NET, and the rest being non-NpD tissues. Immunohistochemistry for MUC5AC was performed using CHL2 and 45M1 clones for IM and MM isoforms, respectively. MUC5AC (both glycoforms) are not detected in non-NpD. In MUC5AC-positive neoplastic tissues, IM was localized to the cytoplasm (Cy) while MM was identified in apical (Ap) and extracellular (Ec) regions too. One ML positive (omentum) in the TMA expressed both. For PDA vs. non-PDA, the sensitivity (SN) was higher with MM ± IM (71%) than MM (47%) or IM (65%)-alone. The specificity (SP) was 100% with MM-alone, which dropped with the addition of IM (96%) or IM-alone (93%). For NpD vs. non-NpD, the SN (MM + IM-59%, IM-55%, MM-37%) was inferior, and SP was 100% for both glycoforms (MM ± IM). The combination of MUC5AC glycoforms has high SP and reasonable SN to diagnose PDA. They have the potential to be a reliable diagnostic marker and should be investigated further in more extensive studies.