Muslim physicians and palliative care: attitudes towards the use of palliative sedation

Abstract

BackgroundMuslim norms concerning palliative sedation can differ from secular and non-Muslim perceptions. Muslim physicians working in a Western environment are expected to administer palliative sedation when medically indicated. Therefore, they can experience tension between religious and medical norms.ObjectiveTo gain insight into the professional experiences of Muslim physicians with palliative sedation in terms of religious and professional norms.DesignInterpretative phenomenological study using semi-structured interviews to take a closer look at the experiences of Muslim physicians with palliative sedation. Data were recorded, transcribed and analysed by means of interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA).ParticipantsTen Muslim physicians, working in the Netherlands, with professional experience of palliative sedation.ResultsTwo main themes were identified: professional self-concept and attitudes towards death and dying. Participants emphasized their professional responsibility when making treatment decisions, even when these contravened the prevalent views of Islamic scholars. Almost all of them expressed the moral obligation to fight their patients’ pain in the final stage of life. Absence of acceleration of death was considered a prerequisite for using palliative sedation by most participants.ConclusionsAlthough the application of palliative sedation caused friction with their personal religious conceptions on a good death, participants followed a comfort-oriented care approach corresponding to professional medical standards. All of them adopted efficient strategies for handling of palliative sedation morally and professionally. The results of this research can contribute to and provide a basis for the emergence of new, applied Islamic ethics regarding palliative sedation.

Allah has told us everything: An interpretative phenomenological analysis exploring the lived experiences of British Muslims

“…Previous studies using IPA have explored a range of topics including how Muslims deal with particular situations (e.g. Muishout et al, 2018; Watts et al, 2014) and how they reconcile aspects of their lives that are perceived as conflicting (e.g. Hunt et al, 2020; Jaspal & Cinnirella, 2014).…”

End-of-life care in intensive care units: A concept analysis

“…We sorted these using the keyword "concept analysis," and 132 papers remained. Some of these papers were found to be related to treatment, such as chemotherapy or sedation, at the end-oflife (Muishout et al, 2018;Somashekhar et al, 2018). Endof-life symptom management is also an important concern in medicine (Khosravani et al, 2020;Mohamed et al, 2016).…”

“…According to Muishout et al (2018), applying palliative sedation is one of the primary issues in end-of-life care in relation to patients' religious and cultural backgrounds. Amblàs-Novellas et al ( 2016) list symptoms that should be managed in the early stages of end-of-life care, including functional and nutritional progression and emotional distress.…”

“…Considering end-of-life preferences of patients with a migration history (Paal & Bükki, 2017), the suppression of end-of-life discussions was associated with suffering and loss of autonomy among migrants. Muishout et al (2018) describe Muslim norms concerning palliative sedation. Simha et al (2013) conducted a research on spiritual concerns among people of the Hindu religion undergoing palliative care.…”

Interpretacyjna Analiza Fenomenologiczna w badaniach jakościowych w psychologii...Przegląd najnowszych badań

“…Wśród omawianych publikacji znajdują się również te podejmujące aktualne problemy z pogranicza psychologii zdrowia, psychologii klinicznej i psychologii międzykulturowej, jak np. prewencja samobójstw (O'Neill, Ennis, McFeeters, & Gallagher, 2018), doświadczenia weteranów wojennych (Unwin & Winder, 2018), duchowość -w tym u osób z problemami natury psychicznej (Forrester-Jones, Dietzfelbinger, Stedman, & Richmond, 2018), czy też pacjentów w opiece paliatywnej (Muishout, van Laarhoven, Wiegers, & Popp-Baier, 2018;Renz et al, 2018) oraz opieka domowa nad osobami z niepełnosprawnością intelektualną (Bright, Hutchinson, Oakes, & Marsland, 2018) i przestępstwa seksualne (Kloess, Larkin, Beech, Hamilton-Giachritsis, 2018). Część badań obejmuje psychologiczne aspekty prokreacji, jak żałoba po utracie dziecka w okresie prenatalnym (Nuzum, Meaney, & O'Donoghue, 2018), przygotowanie do ciąży kobiet z epilepsją (Lawther, Dolk, Sinclair, & Morrow, 2018) i doświadczenie opieki okołoporodowej (Larkin, 2018).…”