Natural and Indigenous sciences: reflections on an attempt to collaborate

Abstract

Natural scientists are increasingly being encouraged to engage with local and Indigenous communities when carrying out research. However, these attempts at collaboration can repeatedly bring up challenges that have their root in how the different stakeholders relate to one another throughout the research process. This essay explores the experiences of the author, an early career researcher trained in the natural sciences, in her attempts to undertake interdisciplinary collaborative work with Sámi reindeer herders in Northern Europe. Whilst underpinned with good intent of creating decolonial, collaborative and locally useful research, the practice of this work lacked awareness of how to do so effectively, leading to multiple challenges in the project. This was largely due to the author having an inadequate understanding of key relevant discourses, including research fatigue, ethics of co-authorship, mismatching timelines, mismatching expectations between academics and relevant communities and power dynamics in interpersonal relationships. These are topics that have been explored in-depth in fields such as human geography, social sciences and anthropology, yet they are insufficiently considered in the natural sciences as a whole. The purpose of this essay is two-fold. The first is to signpost natural scientists wishing to engage in collaborative research towards key texts and concepts that could aid their work. It is not an extensive review, but rather what is hopefully an accessible introduction. It is, quite simply, an essay that the author would have appreciated having access to before undertaking her work. The second is to contribute to a wider discussion around the need for a more diverse and decolonial training in the natural sciences, so we all can respond to the many changes currently occurring on our planet using knowledge generated from well-informed, meaningful and effective collaborations.

Decolonising Fire Science by Reexamining Fire Management across Contested Landscapes: A Workshop Approach

“…This series explored opportunities for participatory research approaches that foreground relationality and experience in the construction of scientific understandings of fire-use communities and landscapes [42,43]. Central to this approach were questions of power, justice, legitimacy, and "otherness", such that we sought to understand how our own situational self-identity impacts our interpretation of the "other"-the research participants-identifying how patterns of power and privilege might shape our inquiries in different contexts [44,45]. This series also addressed the ways in which research can reproduce colonial paradoxes in disciplinary power on decolonisation [40,46].…”

Grand challenges in marine governance for ocean sustainability in the twenty-first century

“…Equitable and just outcomes of biodiversity conservation essentially require a revolution in the ways local and Indigenous communities are engaged in governance, placing them front and center (Armitage et al, 2020). The tools and approaches for this include participatory processes and participatory methods as exemplified in transdisciplinarity (Klein et al, 2001;Mauser et al, 2013;Gómez and Köpsel, 2022;Hills and Maharaj, 2023), co-creation of knowledge through research co-design and knowledge co-production (Norström et al, 2020), the use of arts, narratives and creative practices (Merrie et al, 2018;Paterson et al, 2020;Strand et al, 2022;Whittaker, 2023), and innovative, meaningful partnerships (Charles, 2019;Haelewaters et al, 2021;Kater, 2022) (George and Wiebe, 2020;Trisos et al, 2021;Bourgeois et al, 2022;Spalding et al, 2023).…”

Canada's marine carbon sink: an early career perspective on the state of research and existing knowledge gaps

“…Pathways for early career researchers to meaningfully engage with Indigenous groups and collaborate on climate problems are restricted by institutional undervaluing, graduate student timelines, a lack of funding, and traditional academic metrics of success (e.g., peer-reviewed journal publications). University students, and particularly international students, may lack knowledge about Canada's colonial history and systemic oppression of Indigenous peoples (Godlewska et al 2020) and the ways that natural science research can impact Indigenous communities (Bozhkov et al 2020;Kater 2022). Community relationship building needs to be recognized as a priority investment and should start with mandatory course work on Indigenous history and rights taught by Indigenous instructors to enhance student understanding of the socio-political landscape around their research (Table 2; Wong et al 2020).…”