Nature and Nature Values in Organic Agriculture. An Analysis of Contested Concepts and Values Among Different Actors in Organic Farming

Abstract

ABSTRACT. The relationship between agriculture and nature is a central issue in the current agricultural debate. Organic Farming has ambitions and a special potential in relation to nature. Consideration for nature is part of the guiding principals of organic farming and many organic farmers are committed to protecting natural qualities. However, the issue of nature, landscape, and land use is not straightforward. Nature is an ambiguous concept that involves multiple interests and actors reaching far beyond farmers. The Danish research project Nature Quality in Organic Farming has investigated the relationship between nature and organic farming. This article will focus on an expert workshop held in connection with the project that investigates the way different actors conceptualize nature. Farmers, scientists, and non-governmental organizations came together to discuss their experiences of nature and expectations of organic agriculture. From this interaction, it was clear that nature is a contested notion. Different understandings of nature exist within the three groups and there is disagreement as to whether emphasis should be given to biological qualities, production values, or experiential and aesthetic perspectives. This complexity provides a challenge to organic farming as well as to the implementation of nature considerations in general. It illustrates an underlying battle for the right to define nature and nature quality and essentially decide what organic farmers should work towards. We argue that successful implementation requires organic farmers to carefully consider what expectations they wish to meet. Optimally it is dependent on a dialog between stakeholder interest groups that allows for multivocality and pluralism.

Comparative Economic Assessment of Conventional and Organic Hazelnut Farming in Turkey: Results of Questionnaires from Three Years

“…Consideration of nature is part of the guiding principles of organic farming and the majority of the organic producers are committed to conserving natural resources (Hansen et at., 2006). In fact, some research results indicate that organic farming plays an important role in controlling or mitigating pollutants caused by agriculture.…”

Effects of Climate Change on Agriculture and Its Mitigation Through Climate Smart Agriculture Practices in Nepal

“…Growth promoting bacteria in jholmal increases nitrogen fixation in soil, induce growth hormone production, and control pathogens to enhance crop growth (Rakesh et al, 2017). Organic farming maintains soil fertility by bio-intensive nutrient management, recycling of agricultural wastes, vermicomposting, avoidance or reduction of external inputs, use of natural forms of pest management, and weed control (Goldsmith and Hildeyard 1996;Hansen et al, 2006). Alternate wetting and drying reduces irrigation amount by about 30% and can result in maintaining the yields as that of flooded rice (Bouman et al, 2007).…”

‘Homeland farming’ or ‘rural emancipation’? The discursive overlap between populist and green parties in Hungary

“…(Borras 2019, p. 4) Regardless of its prefixes (right, left, agrarian), populist critique of the current state of agriculture, in many ways congruent with environmentalism, illustrates populist influence across specific political domains. The chameleonic nature of populism enables it to take on the hue of the environment in which it occurs: given the persistent environmental change affecting the developments in agriculture, this can be taken literally (Hansen et al 2006;Ioris 2016). The nexus of populism and environmental concern is yet to receive substantial scholarly attention (Wittmer and Birner 2005;Haggerty 2007;Forchtner and Kølvraa 2015;Lockwood 2018).…”