Negotiating Conflicts of Needs in Designing Teaching English for Midwifery Students

Abstract

As an international lingua franca, English plays an important role for students of health for both academic and career success; however, it is often neglected in its planning and implementation. The present study aims at redesigning the teaching of English for midwifery students using an ESP approach by analyzing present situations (PSA), target situations (TSA), and learning situations (LSA) as the basis for designing English programs. The research was conducted at Midwifery Department, Polytechnic of Health (Politeknik Kesehatan henceforth POLTEKES) Mataram, Indonesia involving students, English lecturers, subject specialists, and management. Data were collected using triangulation techniques -- ECSCS Test, questionnaires, interviews, Focus Group Discussion (FGD), and documentation – and were analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively based on the characteristics of data. The research found that (i) the students’ level of English was still low (84.6% in Basic); (ii) the target needs (necessities) are to be able to communicate both spoken and written in carrying out the duties in workplaces and professional development; (iii) from those results mentioned above, there were conflicts among aspects of needs in designing courses, that is, the high target does not correspond to entry behavior, the number of credits allocated, and facilities. Considering the results of NA, it is suggested that the English programs can be designed using Necessities (TSA)-based Approach, PSA-based Approach, or Mixed Approach with its own advantages and disadvantages

SKDI-Based Needs Analysis for Designing English for Students of Medicine in Indonesia

“…A number of research studies have reported that English at Higher Education becomes one of determining factors of ones' success in both academic and career (Antony, 2018;Daffa-Allah, 2012;Kaur, 2007;Lodhi, Shamim, Robab, Shahzad, & Ashraf, 2018); Poorhadi, 2017;Skelton & Whetstone, 2012;Woodrow, 2018). These studies are aligned with the previous studies conducted by Sujana, Fitriana & Syahrial (2016) and Sujana, Hanafi, Wilian, Syahrial, & Fitriana (2019). These authors found that English was perceived to have an important role to support the professional practices of those studying and working in medical fields.…”

Investigating the English Language Needs of Purchasing Department Employees: A Study of Eop

“…Dudley-evans et al (1998) define needs analysis as the process of establishing the what and how of how of a course. Needs analysis involves finding students' present situation (PSA) and target situation (TSA) before designing curriculum and syllabi (learning needs or LSA) (Sujana et al, 2019).…”

English Need Analysis for Mataram Children Forum in Mataram City

“…It is an invaluable language when it comes to connecting interactions between people all over the world. Sujana, Fitriana, and Syahrial (2016) argue that since English holds such a strong place, learning it is an essential need; otherwise, the people would face challenges if they are unable to communicate effectively in English. It is considered that the majority of people nowadays seek to be fluent in English since they want to have specific opportunities in a variety of ways (Abrejo et al, 2019).…”

“…Finding a gap between the abilities of learners and the skills they need to have are the goals of needs analysis. Due to the complexities of the meanings of need, analyzing information and determining program decisions based on the results of need analysis is a challenging process (Sujana et al, 2019).…”