Nonlinear Effects in Asymmetric Catalysis by Design: Concept, Synthesis, and Applications

Abstract

Conspectus Asymmetric synthesis constitutes a key technology for the preparation of enantiomerically pure compounds as well as for the selective control of individual stereocenters in the synthesis of complex compounds. It is thus of extraordinary importance for the synthesis of chiral drugs, dietary supplements, flavors, and fragrances, as well as novel materials with tunable and reconfigurable chiroptical properties or the assembly of complex natural products. Typically, enantiomerically pure catalysts are used for this purpose. To prepare enantiomerically pure ligands or organocatalysts, one can make use of the natural chiral pool. Ligands and organocatalysts with an atropisomeric biphenyl and binaphthyl system have become popular, as they are configurationally stable and contain a C2-symmetric skeleton, which has been found to be particularly privileged. For catalysts with opposite configurations, both product enantiomers can be obtained. Configurationally flexible biphenyl systems initially appeared to be unsuitable for this purpose, as they racemize after successful enantiomer separation and thus are neither storable nor afford a reproducible enantioselectivity. However, there are strategies that exploit the dynamics of such ligands to stereoconvergently enrich one of the catalyst enantiomers. This can be achieved, for example, by coordinating an enantiomerically pure additive to a ligand–metal complex, which results in deracemization of the configurationally flexible biphenyl system, thereby enriching the thermodynamically preferred diastereomer. In this Account, we present our strategy to design stereochemically flexible catalysts that combine the properties of supramolecular recognition, stereoconvergent alignment, and catalysis. Such systems are capable to recognize the chirality of the target product, leading to an increase in enantioselectivity during asymmetric catalysis. We have systematically developed and investigated these smart catalyst systems and have found ways to specifically design and synthesize them for various applications. In addition to (i) reaction product-induced chiral amplification, we have developed systems with (ii) intermolecular and (iii) intramolecular recognition, and successfully applied them in asymmetric catalysis. Our results pave the way for new applications such as temperature-controlled enantioselectivity, controlled inversion of enantioselectivity with the same chirality of the recognition unit, generation of positive nonlinear effects, and targeted design of autocatalytic systems through dynamic formation of transient catalysts. Understanding such systems is of enormous importance for catalytic processes leading to symmetry breaking and amplification of small imbalances of enantiomers and offer a possible explanation of homochirality of biological systems. In addition, we are learning how to target supramolecular interactions to enhance enantioselectivities in asymmetric catalysis through secondary double stereocontrol. Configurationally flexible catalysts will enabl...

Rationalizing the Extent of the “Sergeants‐and‐Soldiers” Effect in Supramolecular Helical Catalysts: Effect of Copper Coordination

“…Non-linear effects, [1,2] asymmetric auto-replication, [3] and additive Horeau amplification of enantioselectivity [4] all refer to an enhancement of the optically purity of small molecules relatively to expectations, and as such, their implication in the emergence of biological homochirality is attractive, even though speculative yet. [5,6] Taming the chiral nature of macromolecules offers another angle to tackle the challenging question of the origin of homochiral nature of biopolymers as well as to construct innovative chiral materials.…”

Enantioselective Self-Replicators

“…Much more than a simple curiosity of nature, it is essential for the exceptional efficiency in information transfer, − catalysis, and electron transfer of today’s biomolecules and confers directionality to molecular and cellular motion. − Hence, homochirality is likely to play an important role in the emergence of function in the transition from chemistry to biology. ,, How biological homochirality arose from a (close to) racemic world is thus a question that intrigues. In the past decades, the scientific community has devoted much effort to study chiral amplification − and symmetry breaking processes. , Most of these efforts have been directed at the polymerization of peptides and oligonucleotides, − crystallization, , and asymmetric autocatalysis of small molecules, − of which the Soai reaction is a famous example. − An overview of these systems is provided in and . In many instances, autocatalysis plays an important role in the emergence of homochirality.…”

Molecular Understanding and Practical In Silico Catalyst Design in Computational Organocatalysis and Phase Transfer Catalysis—Challenges and Opportunities

“…A non-linear relationship between the catalyst % ee and the product % ee , known as the non-linear effect (NLE) [ 118 , 119 ], signals the aggregation of catalyst molecules. However, one should note that the observation of NLE does not guarantee the involvement of catalyst aggregation [ 120 , 121 ].…”