Objective Comparison of White Light and Narrow‐Band Imaging for Detecting Scars, Sulci and Nodules

Abstract

IntroductionNarrow‐band imaging (NBI) can improve detection of lesions in the aerodigestive tract. However, its role in benign lesions of the larynx is unclear. This study aims to determine whether NBI improves the detection of scars, sulci, and nodules compared to panchromatic lighting using objective image analysis.MethodsIn total, 120 vocal folds (VFs) were analyzed with and without NBI (21 normal, 15 scars, 16 sulci, and 45 nodules). Each VF image had anterior, middle, and posterior thirds analyzed for brightness using an area morphometry software (Optimas 5.1a). The middle‐third with the lesion was analyzed against surrounding VF segments for average and standard deviation (SD) in absolute grayscale.ResultsThe use of panchromatic light resulted in greater illumination and grayscale values than NBI. All lesions tended to be in the mid‐membranous fold. Under panchromatic light, change in brightness when comparing anterior versus middle (A–M) was +6.1% for normal, versus 6.5%, 8.1%, and 7.1% for sulci, nodules, and scars, respectively. Under NBI, they were 9.0% (normal), 12.3% (sulci), 13.7% (nodules), and 13.1% (scars). A greater SD of luminescence was observed at pathology sites (p < 0.05) when using NBI. The change in absolute grayscale at all lesion sites was greater when using NBI than when using panchromatic light (p < 0.05).ConclusionNBI significantly enhanced the area of pathology in patients with nodules, sulci, and scars. Greater SD values in grayscale at pathologic sites were observed compared at normal sites. Thus, NBI may improve the detection of phonotraumatic lesions compared to panchromatic light.Level of EvidenceN/A Laryngoscope, 2024