“…While this model can, perhaps, explain Sr and Nd isotopic systematics, it fails to explain combined Pb, Sr, and Nd systematics (and hence also correlated Hf isotopes), both in Hawaii (Roden et al, 1984) and elsewhere (White, 2010). An alternative proposed by White and Duncan (1996) for the Society Islands and Fekiacova et al (2007) for Hawaii is that rejuvenescent magmas are generated by melting of the sheath of more depleted material entrained by the plume as it rises through the deep mantle. In the Bianco et al (2005) model, the plume consists of a mixture of pods and lenses of pyroxenite and/or incompatible element-enriched peridotite distributed more or less uniformly in a matrix of depleted peridotite, the latter with a higher solidus temperature than the two former.…”