P3518Men with heart failure have higher readmission rates: a closer review of sex and gender based analyses

Abstract

Background There has been increased attention on reducing hospital readmission rates. However, little is known about any difference in readmission rates in heart failure by sex, although evidence exists demonstrating differences in the etiology of heart failure. As a result, strategies to optimize readmission reduction programs and care strategies for women and men remain unclear. Purpose (1) To identify studies examining readmission rates according to sex, and (2) to provide a qualitative overview of possible considerations for the impact of sex or gender. Methods A scoping protocol was developed using the Arksey and O'Malley framework and the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology. Our search strategy was reviewed according to the peer-review of electronic search strategy (PRESS) checklist. Full text articles published between 2002 and 2017 and drawn from multiple databases (i.e. MEDLINE, EMBASE), grey literature (i.e. National Technical Information, Duck Duck Go), and experts were consulted for additional articles. Screening criteria were established a priori. Once an acceptable inter-rater agreement was established at 80% by two independent reviewers, articles were screened for potential eligibility. A descriptive analytical method was employed to chart primary research articles. Articles were considered relevant if the cohort consisted of adult heart failure patients who were readmitted after an index hospitalization and a sex/gender-based analysis was performed. Results The literature search yielded 5887 articles, of which 746 underwent full text assessment for eligibility. Of 164 eligible articles, 34 studies addressed the primary outcome, 103 studies considered sex differences as a secondary outcome and 25 studies included disaggregated data for sex but no subsequent interaction was reported. Good inter-rater agreement was reached: 83% for title and abstract screening; 88% for full text review; kappa: 0.69 (95% CI: 0.526–0.851). Twelve of 34 studies included for the primary outcome reported higher readmission rates for men compared to five studies reporting higher readmission rates for women. However, there were differential readmission rates that were dependent on duration of follow-up. Women were more likely to experience higher readmission rates than men when time to event was less than one year. Readmission rates for men were higher when follow-up was longer than one year. Conclusion Sex differences in readmission rates were dependent on follow up time. Most studies used composite outcomes and had short times to event, which may mask underlying effects of sex on readmission. Acknowledgement/Funding Ontario SPOR Support Unit