“…Hence, it was suggested that particles introduced to surface waters by river input or biological production are removed by surface advection (Yang and Haley, 2016) and possibly recycled/remineralized in the mixed layer, minimizing export to the deeper water column. Our new [pREE] data, however, show pREEs are still present in the deeper water column and that the pREE concentration range is similar to that at several locations in the Atlantic Ocean, for which [pREE] data exist (e.g., Sholkovitz et al, 1994;Tachikawa et al, 1999;van de Flierdt et al, 2012;Garcia-Solsona et al, 2014;Lagarde et al, 2020). The pREE concentration range in this study over the entire water column at the open ocean stations (stations 50-101) is from 0.1 to 0.9 pmol/kg Nd.…”