Patients’ experiences with the advanced practice nurse role in Swiss family practices: a qualitative study

Abstract

Background: Considering shortages of general practitioners (GP) and strategies for improving the quality of health care provision, many countries have implemented interprofessional care models with advanced practice nurses (APN). International evidence suggests that APN care results in high patient satisfaction. In Switzerland, the role is still new, and the patient perspective has not yet been researched. Our aim was therefore to explore patients’ experiences with the APN role in Swiss family practices.Methods: We conducted 22 semi-structured interviews in four different family practices with patients aged 18 to 97 suffering from minor acute to multiple chronic diseases, and who had at least one consultation with an APN. All interviews were audiotaped, transcribed verbatim, and analysed using qualitative content analysis.Results: The analysis resulted in five themes: Despite the unfamiliarity, all patients were willing to be consulted by an APN because it was recommended by their GP (1); after several encounters, most participants perceived differences between the APN and the GP consultation in terms of the length and approach of the consultations as well as the complexity of their tasks (2); the interviewees emphasised coaching, guidance, care coordination, and GP-assisting tasks as APN core competencies and attributed the characteristics empathetic, trustworthy, and competent to the APN role (3); most patients especially valued home visits and the holistic approach of the APNs, but they also noticed that in certain cases GP supervision was required (4); and due to the close collaboration between the APN and the GP, patients felt safe, well cared for and experienced improvements in physical and psychological well-being as well as in daily activities (5). Conclusion: Our results suggest that patients value the APNs’ competencies, despite their initial lack of role knowledge. Trust in the GP seems to be the most important factor for patients’ receptiveness toward the APN role. Overall, patients perceived an added value due to the enlargement of the scope of practice offered by APNs. The patient perspective might provide valuable insights for further APN role implementation in Swiss family practices.

Advanced practice role delineation within Finland: A comparative descriptive study

“…The importance of generalist, specialist and advanced practice nursing (APN) roles to healthcare systems, for improving population health, providing better quality of care and decrease healthcare costs, is demonstrated through substantive review evidence (Brooten et al, 2012; Bryant‐Lukosius & Martin‐Misener, 2016; Coster et al, 2018; Kilpatrick et al, 2014) and highlighted further by patient perception of added value and satisfaction (Jennings et al, 2015; Schönenberger et al, 2020). The World Health Organization (2015) also voices the need to optimize the introduction of specialized and advanced roles in healthcare systems.…”

Interprofessionelle Zusammenarbeit in der Gesundheitsversorgung

“…Die meist genannten Hindernisse für eine gelingende interprofessionelle Zusammenarbeit sind Zeitmangel, fehlende Ausbildung, unklare Aufgabengebiete, Ängste in Bezug auf die berufliche Identität und schlechte Kommunikation [5]. Eine oft noch wenig genutzte, aber wirkungsvolle Unterstützung ist die Integration von Pflegeexpertinnen und -experten ANP (Advanced Nursing Practice) in die reguläre Gesundheitsversorgung; wie eine am Zentrum für Hausarztmedizin und Community Care der Universität Luzern durchgeführte qualitative Studie zeigt sind die Akzeptanz in der Grundversorgung und der Mehrwert für die Patientinnen und Patienten vorhanden [6].…”

Delphi survey on the application of advanced practice nursing competencies: Strong points and unfinished business in cancer care

“…The professional role of the advanced practice nurse (APN) has emerged as an innovative solution to health care needs, providing a high degree of knowledge, expertise and autonomy in patient care (Hutchinson et al, 2014; Krishnasamy et al, 2021; Sánchez‐Gómez et al, 2019). At the international level, implementation and regulation are uneven: in some countries, these roles have been established for decades, while in others, implementation has not yet reached its optimal level (Carney, 2016; Schönenberger et al, 2020; Westman et al, 2019).…”