Performance measurement in Islamic microfinance institutions: does it change social norms and values?

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to examine the influence of financial performance measures on the social norms and values of an Islamic microfinance institution (IMFI), and the actions taken by the organisational members to maintain these values in their organisation. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative case study of an NGO-based IMFI in Malaysia was undertaken, with interviews conducted with officers and managers at various organisational levels of the IMFI. Insights gained from institutional work and institutional logic were used to theorise the findings. Findings The IMFI used mainly financial measures to manage its performance, which were interlinked with the commercialisation approach in the industry, and the top management’s focus on the financial sustainability of the organisation. The lack of social goals and the use of reward-based financial measures did not weaken the solidified social values at the operational level, due to the independence of the operational units, the compartmentalisation of profit-making activities and the institutional work of the operational managers. The operational managers acted as carriers of this social logic. Religious values formed the pillar of the permanence of social values in the IMFI. Originality/value This study provides insights into the internal practices of IMFIs, and the role of religious values in the permanence of social logic in the context of an NGO-based IMFI. The lack of measurable social goals, as well as their rewards, does not compromise the focus on poverty alleviation and community development in view of the intrinsic rewards and accountability of the operational managers.

Empowering Rohingya Refugees through Islamic Microfinance Exploring Prospects and Challenges in Bangladesh

“…They only serve the Rohingya market in Bangladesh because Islamic microfinance from local and international organizations is inadequate. They exclusively operate in Bangladesh (Abdul Zalim, 2022;Ben Salem & Ben Abdelkader, 2023).…”

“…Bangladesh has many Rohingya. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), and UNESCO are among the nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) working to promote human rights and raise awareness (Abdul Zalim, 2022;Ben Salem & Ben Abdelkader, 2023). Since the focus is on registered Rohingya, the unregistered group is overlooked.…”

“…This study is important because it examines how Islamic microfinance can empower Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh (Abdul Zalim, 2022;Al-Dajani, 2022;Purwanto et al, 2022). The results will benefit policymakers, practitioners, and humanitarian organizations in refugee environments.…”

Objectives and measures of performance of Islamic microfinance banks in Indonesia: the stakeholders' perspectives

“…Profit is a target that must be achieved to maintain operations and for IMFIs and conventional microfinance institutions to grow and develop (Tamanni and Haji Besar, 2019). The use of financial measures would not have a significant impact on the IMFI if social values are strongly embedded in the organisation, as shown by Siti-Nabiha and Siti-Nazariah (2021) in their study of an NGO-based IMFI.…”

Socioeconomic Development on Poverty Alleviation of Women Entrepreneurship

“…Microfinance is gaining importance to create jobs, provide income for the poor, and alleviate poverty. Many studies of microfinance look at different programs and institutions providing microfinance support (Khan et al, 2020;Mohamed & Fauziyyah, 2020;Sharma, Guptu, Sharma, & Sharma, 2021;Siti-Nabiha & Siti-Nazirah, 2021).…”