Pharmaceuticals in Tap Water: Human Health Risk Assessment and Proposed Monitoring Framework in China

Abstract

Background: Pharmaceuticals are known to contaminate tap water worldwide, but the relevant human health risks have not been assessed in China.Objectives: We monitored 32 pharmaceuticals in Chinese tap water and evaluated the life-long human health risks of exposure in order to provide information for future prioritization and risk management.Methods: We analyzed samples (n = 113) from 13 cities and compared detected concentrations with existing or newly-derived safety levels for assessing risk quotients (RQs) at different life stages, excluding the prenatal stage.Results: We detected 17 pharmaceuticals in 89% of samples, with most detectable concentrations (92%) at < 50 ng/L. Caffeine (median–maximum, nanograms per liter: 24.4–564), metronidazole (1.8–19.3), salicylic acid (16.6–41.2), clofibric acid (1.2–3.3), carbamazepine (1.3–6.7), and dimetridazole (6.9–14.7) were found in ≥ 20% of samples. Cities within the Yangtze River region and Guangzhou were regarded as contamination hot spots because of elevated levels and frequent positive detections. Of the 17 pharmaceuticals detected, 13 showed very low risk levels, but 4 (i.e., dimetridazole, thiamphenicol, sulfamethazine, and clarithromycin) were found to have at least one life-stage RQ ≥ 0.01, especially for the infant and child life stages, and should be considered of high priority for management. We propose an indicator-based monitoring framework for providing information for source identification, water treatment effectiveness, and water safety management in China.Conclusion: Chinese tap water is an additional route of human exposure to pharmaceuticals, particularly for dimetridazole, although the risk to human health is low based on current toxicity data. Pharmaceutical detection and application of the proposed monitoring framework can be used for water source protection and risk management in China and elsewhere.

Occurrence of Pharmaceuticals in Wastewater and Their Interaction with Shallow Aquifers: A Case Study of Horní Beřkovice, Czech Republic

“…These substances may greatly affect the resistance of bacteria and, consequently, pose a human health risk. A study from China [25] detected several pharmaceuticals in tap water and attempted to assess the human health risk of selected substances based on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA's) Exposure Factors Handbook.…”

Can environmental pharmaceuticals be photocatalytically degraded and completely mineralized in water using g-C3N4/TiO2 under visible light irradiation?—Implications of persistent toxic intermediates

“…Pharmaceuticals and their metabolites are becoming increasing ubiquitous in aquatic environments and even in drinking water. These chemicals are introduced as a result of human and animal use, or as residues from manufacturers and hospitals [1][2][3]. The continuous usage and perfusion of these pharmaceutical compounds in water environments may make them "pseudo-persistent," even if they have short half-lives [4,5].…”

Pharmaceutical Dispensing and Wasting In Health Care Facilities, Amounts, Costs and Evaluation of Potential Ecologic Effects

“…Direct relationships between the low levels of pharmaceuticals identified in drinking water and adverse impacts to human health are not being observed at this time [46,47]. However, numerous laboratory studies [48][49][50][51][52][53][54][55][56] and literature reviews [57][58][59] have demonstrated the negative impacts of drugs to aquatic organisms.…”