The use of bivalirudin as the primary anticoagulant for children supported on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is growing. Ideal management of bivalirudin dosing during therapeutic plasma exchange (TPE) on ECMO is unknown. We performed a single-center retrospective study of ECMO patients anticoagulated with bivalirudin who underwent TPE from January 2019 to December 2021. Therapeutic plasma exchange sessions were analyzed individually by bivalirudin dosing strategy (no change [NC] versus increased dose [dose change {DC} bivalirudin group]) and replacement fluid (all fresh–frozen plasma [FFP] versus all albumin or FFP and albumin [FFP/Albumin]). Primary outcomes included bleeding, coagulopathy, and circuit thrombosis within 24 hours of TPE. Secondary outcomes included change in bivalirudin dose and coagulation parameters following TPE. There were 60 unique TPE sessions. Bivalirudin dosing or replacement fluid strategies were not associated with bleeding, coagulopathy, or thrombosis post-TPE. All albumin or fresh frozen plasma and albumin combinations (FFP/Albumin) group had longer post-TPE thromboelastography (TEG) reaction time, clot time, and more acute angle. The FFP/Albumin group had increased post-TPE international normalization ratio (INR) and partial thrombin time (PTT). Therapeutic plasma exchange for children on ECMO and bivalirudin anticoagulation is feasible; however, optimal dosing during TPE requires further investigation. Replacement fluid with FFP/Albumin is associated with more coagulopathic laboratory parameters. Patients may benefit from all FFP fluid replacement strategy. Further investigation is needed to prove generalizability.