Private Information in Healthcare Utilization: Specification of a Copula-Based Hurdle Model

Abstract

Summary We study whether individuals' private information on health risk affects their medical care utilization. The presence of such information asymmetry is critical to the optimal payment design in healthcare systems. To do so, we examine the relationship between self‐perceived health status and healthcare expenditures. Because of simultaneity, we employ a copula regression to model jointly the mixed outcomes, with the association parameter capturing the residual dependence conditional on covariates. The semicontinuous nature of healthcare expenditures leads to a two‐part interpretation of private health information: the hurdle component assesses its effect on the likelihood of using medical care services, and the conditional component quantifies its effect on the expenditures given consumption of care. The methodology proposed is applied to a survey data set of a sample of the US civilian non‐institutionalized population to test and quantify the effects of private health information. We find evidence of adverse selection in the utilization of various types of medical care services.

Dependent frequency–severity modeling of insurance claims

“…Using copulas for mixed multivariate outcomes is less common in the actuarial literature. Some recent applications are Czado et al (2012), Krämer et al (2013) and Shi and Zhang (2014). According to the Sklar's theorem, the joint distribution of N * i and S * i has a copula representation:…”

Coordination of elderly healthcare service supply chain with information asymmetry: Designs of option contracts under different demand distribution statuses

“…Shi and Zhang claimed that information asymmetry contributed to the high rising healthcare costs. They examined the existence of private information among the patient and healthcare institutions and further quantified its effect on the utilization of medical care services based on a copula-based hurdle model [31]. Yan et al conducted a questionnaire survey to analyse differences between the transparency of information disclosure and related demands from the customers perspective, and further studied the influence of different levels of mandatory information disclosure on the relationship between the service providers and customers [39].…”

Multiperil Rate Making for Property Insurance Using Longitudinal Data

“…The GB2 distribution was introduced by McDonald () and has found extensive applications in the economics literature (McDonald and Xu, ). More recently, Frees and Valdez () and Shi and Zhang () considered an alternative parameterization and demonstrated its flexibility in fitting insurance claims and healthcare expenditures. GB2 is a member of the log‐location–scale family with location parameter μ it , j , scale parameter σ j and shape parameters ϕ 1 j and ϕ 2 j .…”