Process evaluation of health system costing – Experience from CHSI study in India

Abstract

Background A national study, 'Costing of healthcare services in India' (CHSI) aimed at generating reliable healthcare cost estimates for health technology assessment and price-setting is being undertaken in India. CHSI sampled 52 public and 40 private hospitals in 13 states and used a mixed micro-costing approach. This paper aims to outline the process, challenges and critical lessons of cost data collection to feed methodological and quality improvement of data collection. Methods An exploratory survey with 3 components-an online semi-structured questionnaire, group discussion and review of monitoring data, was conducted amongst CHSI data collection teams. There were qualitative and quantitative components. Difficulty in obtaining individual data was rated on a Likert scale. Results Mean time taken to complete cost data collection in one department/speciality was 7.86 (±0.51) months, majority of which was spent on data entry and data issues resolution. Data collection was most difficult for determination of equipment usage (mean difficulty score 6.59±0.52), consumables prices (6.09±0.58), equipment price(6.05±0.72), and furniture price(5.64±0.68). Human resources, drugs & consumables contributed to 78% of total cost and 31% of data collection time. However, furniture, overheads and equipment consumed 51% of time contributing only 9% of total cost. Seeking multiple permissions, absence of electronic records, multiple sources of data were key challenges causing delays.

Cost effectiveness of typhoid vaccination in India

“…Similarly, CHSI study provides mean unit cost for outpatient and inpatient care for the medicine department based on cost data collection from 52 tertiary care facilities across 13 Indian states. These mean cost values all capital and recurrent inputs included in the delivery of health care that were estimated through mixed top-down and bottom-up economic costing methods [36] , [37] .…”

Cost-Effectiveness of Temozolamide for Treatment of Glioblastoma Multiforme in India

“…Average cost of management in inpatient setting, routine or intensive care, was obtained from the National Health System Cost Database and analysis of recently conducted nationally representative hospital costing study. 30 , 31 Price of drug temozolamide was accessed from an online source named Indiamart, which provides wholesale prices of medical supplies. 32 A range of temozolamide prices by multiple brands were available through this website, and therefore, a mean price was considered appropriate for the current analysis.…”

Cost-effectiveness of Tamoxifen, Aromatase Inhibitor, and Switch Therapy (Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy) for Breast Cancer in Hormone Receptor Positive Postmenopausal Women in India

“… 50 The cost of management of an osteoporotic fracture was calculated using weighted average based on frequency of different sites of fracture in breast cancer patients. 6 All the costs were determined from either an existing costing study, Costing of Health Services in India (CHSI) 51 , 52 or from nationally representative payment rates as listed under the national insurance scheme Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB PM-JAY) 53 ( Table 2 ).…”