Public health preparedness and response synergies between institutional authorities and the community: a qualitative case study of emerging tick-borne diseases in Spain and the Netherlands

Abstract

Background Communities affected by infectious disease outbreaks are increasingly recognised as partners with a significant role to play during public health emergencies. This paper reports on a qualitative case study of the interactions between affected communities and public health institutions prior to, during, and after two emerging tick-borne disease events in 2016: Crimean-Congo Haemorrhagic Fever in Spain, and Tick-Borne Encephalitis in the Netherlands. The aim of the paper is to identify pre-existing and emergent synergies between communities and authorities, and to highlight areas where synergies could be facilitated and enhanced in future outbreaks. Methods Documentary material provided background for a set of semi-structured interviews with experts working in both health and relevant non-health official institutions (13 and 21 individuals respectively in Spain and the Netherlands), and focus group discussions with representatives of affected communities (15 and 10 individuals respectively). Data from all sources were combined and analysed thematically, initially independently for each country and then for both countries together. Results Strong synergies were identified in tick surveillance activities in both countries, and the value of pre-existing networks of interest groups for preparedness and response activities was recognised. However, authorities also noted that there were hard-to-reach and potentially vulnerable groups, such as hikers, foreign tourists, and volunteers working in green areas. While the general population received preventive information about the two events, risk communication or other community engagement efforts were not seen as necessary specifically for these sub-groups. Post-event evaluations of community engagement activities during the two events were limited, so lessons learned were not well documented. Conclusions A set of good practices emerged from this study, that could be applied in these and other settings. They included the potential value of conducting stakeholder analyses of community actors with a stake in tick-borne or other zoonotic diseases; of utilising pre-existing stakeholder networks for information dissemination; and of monitoring community perceptions of any public health incident, including through social media. Efforts in the two countries to build on the community engagement activities that are already in place could contribute to better preparedness planning and more efficient and timely responses in future outbreaks.

The contribution of citizen science in the surveillance of wildlife and related arthropods

“…Firstly, the possibility for scientists to provide public health education and open access to scientific findings for participants. In addition, CS may be a way to spread medical knowledge to geographic areas where such information is poorly available, such as in rural settlements that are commonly characterized by limited public health services (de Vries et al, 2018). In these environmental contexts, CS may be a useful tool for supporting hard-to-reach populations (i.e.…”

Risk communication and community engagement with vulnerable groups: Perceptions of social-services CSOs during Covid-19

“…Although the importance of community engagement during Public Health emergencies has been widely recognized it has been largely employed in contexts of the Global South, or in low-income countries [ [13] , [14] , [15] ]. Studies on community engagement during Covid-19 in high income countries note two things: First, community engagement was more difficult due to Covid-19 measures because direct contact and access to public spaces (e.g.…”

Awareness and Community Engagement in Zoonotic Disease Management

“…Here are potential barriers to effective communication and community involvement in zoonotic disease management, along with suggested solution i) Implement multi-channel communication tactics that reach varied demographics, including radio broadcasts, community meetings, and mobile messaging services. (de Vries et al 2021) ii) Provide information in local languages and use visuals and info graphics for enhanced comprehension. (Efua 2023) iii) Establish a consolidated, reputable source of information on zoonotic diseases that is routinely updated with correct and validated information.…”