Recidivism after Release from a Prison Nursery Program

Abstract

Objective To analyze three-year recidivism after release from a prison nursery, a secure unit that allows imprisoned women to care for their infants. Design and Sample Descriptive study of 139 women who co-resided with their infants between 2001–2007 in X prison nursery. Measurement Administrative criminal justice data were analyzed along with prospective study data on demographic, mental health, and prison nursery policy-related factors. Results Results reflect a sample of young women of color with histories of clinically significant depressive symptoms and substance dependence, who were convicted of nonviolent crimes and had multiple prior arrests. Three years after release 86.3% remained in the community. Only 4% of women returned to prison for new crimes. Survival modeling indicated that women who had previously violated parole had a significantly shorter mean return to prison time than those who were in the nursery for a new crime. Conclusion Women released from a prison nursery have a low likelihood of recidivism. Innovative interventions are needed to address incarceration’s public health effects. Nurses can partner with criminal justice organizations to develop, implement, and evaluate programs to ensure the health needs of criminal justice involved people and their families are met.

Making mothers in jail: carceral reproduction of normative motherhood

“…Documentaries feature testimonials from women who describe, through tears, how being able to bond with their babies despite, or in some cases in spite of, being in prison changed their lives, helped them parent and gave them confidence (McShane, 2011). Research studies have reported that women in these programmes have lower recidivism rates (Goshin et al, 2014). Such reports project a synergism and idealism in the ability of parenting and incarceration to assist a mother in transformation to someone who is an upstanding citizen and a ‘worthy’ mother.…”

When the Punishment is Pregnancy: Carceral Restriction of Abortion in the United States

“…The idea is that having the time and space to cultivate their maternal identity will help them refocus away from a life of crime and toward one of normativity. Research publications claim that women who participate in these programs have lower reincarceration rates (Goshin, Byrne, and Henninger 2014). So it seems there is at least indirect evidence that prisons perceive a continued pregnancy to have rehabilitative and crime‐deterring potential, thus serving a penological interest.…”

Mãe E Filho No Cárcere: Uma Revisão Sistemática

“…Nova York demonstraram que, nos últimos 30 anos, a população carcerária feminina dos Estados Unidos aumentou, tornando-se, assim, um grande problema de saúde pública, pois mais de 60% dessas mulheres presas têm mais de 2 filhos e de 6-10% engravidam nesse contexto (5,7) .…”