“…Unfortunately, the authors do not discuss eventual changes of the a parameter during this process, but they mention that this cubic phase does not exist in superconducting quenched YPd B C and as-cast or quenched YPd B C . Let us note that in Th-Pd-B-C also, two superconducting phases have been reported (¹ &14-15 K and ¹ &19-20 K) (18,19) and that both quaternary tetragonal (19,46,50) and ternary cubic phases (46) have been found from HREM and are supposed to be responsible for superconductivity. The cubic phase (primitive, a"4.2 A > ) could be ThPd B (probably CaB -type), and it may be responsible for ¹ &21 K. In order to improve the knowledge of the phase diagram and look for other compositions, close to those of previous quaternaries that could be responsible for superconductivity, we prepared and studied Table 1) only in Y Pd B K C with m57 in a sample containing a large number of phases.…”