Secchi Depth Retrieval in Oligotrophic to Eutrophic Chilean Lakes Using Open Access Satellite-Derived Products

Abstract

The application of the Multispectral Instrument (MSI) aboard Sentinel-2A/B constellation for assessing water quality in Chilean lakes represents an emerging area of research, particularly for the environmental monitoring of optically complex water bodies. Similarly, atmospheric correction processors applied to aquatic environments, such as the Case 2 Networks (C2RCC-Nets), are notably underrepresented. This study evaluates the capability of C2RCC-Nets using different neural networks—Case-2 Regional/Coast Color (C2RCC), C2X-Extreme (C2X), and C2X-Complex (C2XC)—to estimate Secchi depth in Lake Lanalhue (eutrophic), Lake Villarrica (oligo-mesotrophic), and Lake Panguipulli (oligotrophic). The evaluation used different statistical methods such as Spearman’s correlation and normalized error metrics (nRMSE, nMAE, and nbias) to assess the agreement between satellite-derived data and in situ measurements. C2XC demonstrated the best fit for Lake Lanalhue, with an nRMSE = 33.13%, nMAE = 23.51%, and nbias = 8.57%, in relation to the median ground truth values. In Lake Villarrica, the C2XC neural network displayed a moderate correlation (rs = 0.618) and error metrics, with an nRMSE of 24.67% and nMAE of 20.67%, with an nbias of 4.21%. In the oligotrophic Lake Panguipulli, no relationship was observed between estimated and measured values, which could be related to the fact that the selected neural networks were developed for very case 2 waters. These findings highlight the need for methodological advancements in processing satellite-derived water quality products for Chile’s optical water types, particularly for very clear waters. Nonetheless, this study underscores the need for model-specific calibration of C2RCC-Nets, as lakes with different optical water types and trophic states may require tailored training ranges for inherent optical properties.