Sequential Molecular Events of Functional Trade-Offs in 5-Hydroxyisourate Hydrolase Before and After Gene Duplication Led to the Evolution of Transthyretin During Chordate Diversification

Abstract

Transthyretin (TTR), a plasma thyroid hormone distributor protein (THDP), emerged from 5-hydroxyisourate hydrolase (HIUHase), an enzyme involved in urate metabolism, by gene duplication at a stage of chordate evolution. Comparison of amino acid sequences revealed the presence of two His-rich segments in the primitive TTRs. Using several HIUHase and TTR mutants, we investigated 5-hydroxyisourate (HIU) hydrolysis activity and thyroid hormone (TH) binding activity to elucidate how a novel function as a THDP arose. Lancelet HIUHase was found to have higher enzyme activity than trout HIUHase. Two amino acid substitutions, R54E/Y119T, at the active sites of HIUHase, exerted weak [I]-3,3',5-triiodo-L-thyronine ([I]T3) binding activity with a concomitant loss of HIU hydrolysis activity. Addition of 3×His (3×H) to the N-terminal end weakened HIU hydrolysis activity of both lancelet and trout HIUHases, whereas it enhanced T3-binding activity of HIUHase R54E/Y119T. Trout HIUHase 3×H R54E/Y119T had higher [I]T3-binding activity than that of lancelet HIUHase 3×H R54E/Y119T, with a K of 143 nM, and displayed metal dependency and no TH binding specificity. Deletion of the N-terminal His-rich segment from lamprey TTR decreased T3-binding activity, while addition of 3×H to trout TTR increased T3-binding activity, while maintaining TH binding specificity. Our results suggest that functional trade-offs of HIU hydrolysis activity with TH binding activity might have sequentially occurred before and after gene duplication, and that TH binding specificity and high-affinity sites may have been acquired later in the course of TTR evolution.