Serious Overestimation in Quantitative PCR by Circular (Supercoiled) Plasmid Standard: Microalgal pcna as the Model Gene

Abstract

Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) has become a gold standard for the quantification of nucleic acids and microorganism abundances, in which plasmid DNA carrying the target genes are most commonly used as the standard. A recent study showed that supercoiled circular confirmation of DNA appeared to suppress PCR amplification. However, to what extent to which different structural types of DNA (circular versus linear) used as the standard may affect the quantification accuracy has not been evaluated. In this study, we quantitatively compared qPCR accuracies based on circular plasmid (mostly in supercoiled form) and linear DNA standards (linearized plasmid DNA or PCR amplicons), using proliferating cell nuclear gene (pcna), the ubiquitous eukaryotic gene, in five marine microalgae as a model gene. We observed that PCR using circular plasmids as template gave 2.65-4.38 more of the threshold cycle number than did equimolar linear standards. While the documented genome sequence of the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana shows a single copy of pcna, qPCR using the circular plasmid as standard yielded an estimate of 7.77 copies of pcna per genome whereas that using the linear standard gave 1.02 copies per genome. We conclude that circular plasmid DNA is unsuitable as a standard, and linear DNA should be used instead, in absolute qPCR. The serious overestimation by the circular plasmid standard is likely due to the undetected lower efficiency of its amplification in the early stage of PCR when the supercoiled plasmid is the dominant template.

Performance of Two Quantitative PCR Methods for Microbial Source Tracking of Human Sewage and Implications for Microbial Risk Assessment in Recreational Waters

“…The average r 2 value for all reaction runs was 0.98 for both targets, with average reaction efficiencies of 83% and 81% for HF183 and HPyVs, respectively. These relatively low efficiency values likely resulted from use of circular rather than linear plasmid DNA, as has been previously suggested (23). Inhibition control.…”

Enumeration of Parasitic Chytrid Zoospores in the Columbia River via Quantitative PCR

“…Although the average amplification efficiencies were slightly lower than 90%, the differences between the efficiencies of the different absolute standards were small (ϳ1%). The parallel analysis of standards allowed us to calculate the difference in ITS2 copy numbers per zoospore determined from an uncut (circular) versus a cut (linearized) plasmid standard, known to show discrepancies in eukaryotic cells (33). Analysis of the circular plasmid overestimated the values compared to analysis of the linearized plasmid, where the circular plasmid C T values were an average of 5.76 Ϯ 0.72 (mean Ϯ standard deviation) higher than the linearized plasmid values for the same DNA concentration (Fig.…”

Addition of activated switchgrass biochar to an aridic subsoil increases microbial nitrogen cycling gene abundances

“…All qPCR assays included negative controls without template, as well as reactions containing between 10 1 and 10 9 DNA copies to generate standard curves and calculate amplification efficiencies according to the equation: E = 10 [−1/slope] (Pfaffl, 2001). DNA standards consisted of linearized plasmids carrying the appropriate target gene (Hou et al, 2010), which were sequenced to confirm their identity and primer binding site. Each assay was performed in triplicate, with triplicate measurements for each sample.…”