Shelving Issues: Patrolling the Boundaries of Democratic Discussion in Public Meetings

Abstract

Democratic participation is widely viewed as a crucial underpinning of legitimate governance; however, little is known about how this participation is practically accomplished. This study contributes to a better understanding of what democratic citizenship encompasses in actual practices of public engagement. Using conversation analysis and discursive psychology, we analyze interactions between government officials and citizens in Dutch public meetings on the effects of livestock farming. We examine situations where citizens treat officials’ closing-implicative moves as “wanting to shelve” issues. We demonstrate how this uptake is preceded by officials treating citizens as not understanding what is within the scope of discussion, thereby challenging their democratic competence. Citizens subsequently turn the tables on the officials, treating them as not wanting to fulfill their democratic duties. We argue that these practices point to broader relational issues between government and citizens, transforming what seem mere agenda issues into negotiations about what constitutes good democracy.

Light At The End Of The Tunnel? The Staging of Expertise During the COVID-19 Vaccination Campaign

“…Dialogue, in contrast to debate, explores routinely hidden moralities, i.e., that what people deem important, in relationships, in life, as a person -and brings them to the surface for discussion (cf. Durnová, 2019;van Burgsteden & te Molder, 2022;van Burgsteden et al, 2022avan Burgsteden et al, , 2022b. Whereas debate can be useful in that it provides an overview of the different existing positions, the focus on defending one's own position hinders people's attempts to better understand and overcome their differences.…”

Going against the interactional tide: The accomplishment of dialogic moments from a conversation analytic perspective

“…The case presented is from a larger corpus of data of recorded Dutch public meetings on livestock farming (Van Burgsteden and Te Molder, 2021, 2022; Van Burgsteden et al, 2022). The topic of livestock farming recurrently involves heated social debate in the Netherlands, and is characterized by a diversity of viewpoints, interests, and risk perceptions (Borlée, 2018).…”