“…Nb-based materials are of scientific interest as a key trace element in Earth's evolutionary process (Sanloup et al, 2018) and multi-functionalities e.g. superconductors (Abud et al, 2017;Shimizu et al, 2018;Ishizu & Kitagawa, 2019;Guo et al, 2019), structural material (Jansto & Marquis, 2013), medical implants (Xu et al, 2013), catalysts (Ichikuni et al, 2016;Pinto et al, 2018), and electronic (Alharthi et al, 2018) and photonic devices (Sahiner et al, 2016). Multivalent states of Nb (Nb +2 /Nb +4 /Nb +5 ) present the scope for transition between oxidation states and structure under variable external conditions, including pressure (Filonenko & Zibrov, 2001;Tamura, 1972).…”