Spatial evaluation of animal health care accessibility and veterinary shortage in France

Abstract

The decrease in the supply of veterinary healthcare in France adversely affects health of food-producing animals. In a One Health perspective, the health of people, animals and their shared environment are interconnected, and adequate supply of veterinary healthcare is required to ensure public health. Prevention of outbreaks and zoonotic diseases that may impact public health mobilizes a set of public policies, including strengthening veterinary workforce. These policies should be informed by quantification of animal health care accessibility, yet this has not been well characterized. The objective was to quantify the accessibility to veterinary healthcare for cattle, swine, and poultry sectors in France. A Two-Step Floating Catchment Area (2SFCA) approach was used to measure the level of accessibility to veterinary clinics. In the cattle sector, the 2SFCA score indicated relatively high accessibility in the north and south of France, but insufficient accessibility elsewhere. In the swine sector, there was high accessibility in the north east and in north of France, medium accessibility in the south west, and insufficient accessibility elsewhere. Finally, in the poultry sector, all regions had insufficient accessibility. Sensitivity analysis examining the effects of a change in spatial accessibility according to various travel time showed that the optimal threshold to compute 2SFCA score in cattle, swine and poultry sectors were respectively, 45, 60 and 60 min. According to a definition of “underserved area” derived from an official decree and the optimal thresholds to compute 2SFCA, the cattle, swine and poultry sector have on average 75.3, 89.9 and 98.3% underserved area, respectively. We provided evidence that the supply of animal health care was not sufficient and we proposed recommendations on how to assess animal health care accessibility, enabling modelling and visualization of the effects of potential public policies aimed at reducing veterinary shortages.

Spatial accessibility and inequality analysis of rabies-exposed patients to rabies post-exposure prophylaxis clinics in Guangzhou City, China

“…The two-step floating catchment area(2SFCA) method is a widely used approach for evaluating the accessibility of facilities or services [ 18 , 19 , 23 ]. Compared to other methods (e.g.…”

Effectiveness of rural internships for veterinary students to combat veterinary workforce shortages in rural areas

“…Between 2016 and 2020, the percentage of veterinarians in the food animal sector (FAS) plummeted by 18% in France [ 1 ]. The definition and location of a veterinarian shortage in France has been mapped, enabling public and private authorities to establish appropriate measures to address this concern, as done for physician shortage [ 2 ]. France is not unique when it comes to a veterinarian shortage.…”

Correlating Access to Primary Medical Care and Veterinary Care Providers: A Novel Application of Spatial Gravity Modelling

“…Floating catchment models have only rarely been used to evaluate access to veterinary care [ 31 ]. One recent paper used the E2SFCA to suggest a method to optimize rabies vaccination site locations in Southeastern Brazil [ 31 ] and another used the 2SFCA to evaluate spatial access to large animal veterinarians in a region of France [ 33 ]. In a review of the literature, the only other paper found to use any form of this method in veterinary care was a paper published in German relating to access to care for companion animals in Switzerland using a FCA model [ 34 ].…”