“…Over the period 1979 to 2005, 31 papers qualified on the basis of matching all of our inclusion criteria (Appelboom & Struyven 1999;Baldock et al, 1994;Cesarani et al, 2003Cesarani et al, , 2004Ciranni et al, 2002;Gaafar et al, 1999;Gardner et al, 2004;Harwood-Nash, 1979;Hoffmann & Hudgins, 2002;Hughes et al, 2005;Jansen et al, 2002;Kieser et al, 2004;Macleod et al, 2000;Magid et al, 1989;Marx & D'Auria, 1988;Melcher et al, 1997;Mininberg, 2001;Nedden et al, 1994;Notman et al, 1986;Pickering et al, 1990;Previgliano et al, 2003;Ruhli & Boni, 2000a,b;Ruhli et al, 2002;Shin et al, 2003;Sigmund & Minas, 2002;Thekkaniyil et al, 2000;Vahey & Brown, 1984;Yardley & Rutka, 1997). Only three papers had specific, stated hypotheses (9.7%), while 84% stated a purpose, either general or specific, for conducting the study (Table 3).…”