Spontaneously Reported Adverse Reactions for Herbal Medicinal Products and Natural Remedies in Sweden 2007–15: Report from the Medical Products Agency

Abstract

BackgroundIn relation to the extensive use of herbal medicinal products in self-care, the safety information is limited and there is a need for improvement. This study describes spontaneously reported adverse reactions related to herbal medicinal products and natural remedies in Sweden.ObjectivesTo evaluate the characteristics and frequency of adverse events recorded by the Swedish Medical Products Agency, where herbal medicinal products and natural remedies were suspected as causative agents.MethodsAdverse drug reactions reported to the Swedish Medical Product Agency during 2007–15 related to approved herbal medicinal products or natural remedies were included and analysed in the retrospective study. Reports had been assessed for causality when they were lodged and only reports that had been assessed as at least possible were included in the study.ResultsIn total, 116 reports (concerning 259 adverse reactions) related to herbal medicinal products or natural remedies were found in the Swedish national pharmacovigilance database. The active ingredients most frequently suspected during the study period were black cohosh rhizome (15 reports), purple coneflower herb (14 reports) and a combination of extracts of pollen (13 reports). Adverse reactions related to skin and subcutaneous tissue were the most commonly reported reactions.ConclusionsNo previously unknown safety problems have been discovered in the present study. This finding could be explained by a thorough pre-approval assessment of medicinal products and the fact that most herbal preparations in medicinal products have been in clinical use for many years (for traditional herbal medicinal products, the requirements are ≥30 years), i.e. adverse reactions are acknowledged and assessed before approval.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s40801-017-0104-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Safety and Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Norway During the First Wave of the COVID-19 Pandemic Using an Adapted Version of the I-CAM-Q: A Cross-Sectional Survey

“…In addition, many patients who use CAM believe that healing crisis (you get worse before getting better) is a part of the healing process [19]. This together may also be part of the explanation why reported adverse effects from natural remedies are generally low [20].…”

Retrospective Study of Reported Adverse Events Due to Complementary Health Products in Singapore From 2010 to 2016

“…In a hospital-based observational study in Korea from April 2012 to December 2014, gastro-intestinal system disorders, followed by skin-related disorders were the most common adverse events reported in 163 herbal-drug-associated cases ( 58 ). Likewise in Sweden, the most commonly reported adverse reactions to herbal medicinal products or natural remedies were “skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders” and “gastrointestinal disorders” in a 9-year study on adverse events reported to the Swedish Medical Product Agency ( 59 ). “Skin and hypersensitivity reactions” and “gastrointestinal disorders” had also been reported as the two most common health products related adverse events ( 9 , 60 , 61 ).…”

Do We Need Plant Food Supplements? A Critical Examination of Quality, Safety, Efficacy, and Necessity for a New Regulatory Framework

“…In the case of hepatotoxicity, the event was quickly reversible after discontinuation, except in two cases where liver transplantation became necessary and in one case where the event was fatal [64,69]. Also, when ingested as an HMP, black cohosh (C. racemosa) was associated with five serious reports related to the liver as described by Svedlund et al in their study on spontaneously reported adverse reactions resulting from HMPs and natural remedies in Sweden in the time from 2007 to 2015 [71]. Despite the limited available nonclinical and clinical data, liver toxicity has been also associated with the use of black cohosh by the European Community, as discussed in the assessment report pertinent to the European Community herbal monographs on C. racemosa rhizome [72,73].…”