Structure and Historicity of Cultural Tastes. Uses of Multiple Correspondence Analysis and Sociological Theory on Age: The Case of Music and Movies

Abstract

The sociology of cultural tastes and practices seeks, on the one hand, to show how tastes and practices are structured, and on the other hand, to explain them. For this purpose, multivariate analysis, and in particular, multiple correspondence analysis (MCA), has been chosen as the preferred statistical method to support a theory of ‘homology’ between ‘social position’ and preferences. This article reassesses the initial interpretation offered by Bourdieu of the two factor spaces of ‘dominant’ and ‘petit-bourgeois’ tastes in Distinction (1979) and discusses how MCA is used in the sociology of culture as ‘structural homology’, especially one-dimensionally (single-axis reduction) and positionally, without the inclusion of the age variable. The two ways of considering the effect of age are either by excluding it a priori (‘omitted axis’) or by not theorizing it (‘descriptive axis’). We show, using data from the 2008 French Cultural Practices survey on tastes in music and movies, how a factor analysis that incorporates age outlines a generational and historical structuring of tastes. We explain the different dimensions of age in terms of cultural practices and we interpret the level of education in terms of knowledge. The article advocates a model for the interpretation of tastes that is no longer based on the structure of capital, but rather on cultural history and specific competences.

Something ‘Old’, Something ‘New’? The UK Space of Political Attitudes After the Brexit Referendum

“…We have not, however, been able to discern a clear-cut effect of capital composition -educational merits and income levels do not display an inverted pattern in the British space of political attitudes (TAN/right-wing attitudes are found among people with a generally low volume of capital). This finding stands in contrast to previous research in Scandinavia (Flemmen, 2014;Flemmen and Haakestad, 2018;Harrits, 2013) but it goes in line with a preceding failure to identify lifestyle divisions along a capital composition dimension in the UK (Le Roux et al, 2008) and recent updates within Bourdieusian sociology (Glevarec and Cibois, 2020). This, along with the relatively weak associations between class and political attitudes suggests, to our surprise, that the UK political landscape seems overall less 'classed' than in Scandinavia, where much of the previous Bourdieusian research on the topic has been carried out.…”

Class and everyday media use: A case study from Norway

“…It also connects with arguments that age differences are somewhat of an omitted variable in class studies of culture (Edmunds & Turner, 2002;Glevarec & Cibois, 2020).…”

The Swedish space of lifestyles and symbolic domination

“…Those that follow Bourdieu’s lead and construct spaces of lifestyles, however, often find that the opposition between youth culture and traditional culture emerges as a secondary structuring principle of lifestyle spaces, with an axis of voracious engagement versus disengagement in cultural activity, corresponding chiefly with cultural capital, forming the primary dimension (especially Bennett et al, 2009; Savage et al, 2013; also contributions to Coulangeon and Duval, 2015; see Glevarec and Cibois, 2020). This is, in part, a product of analyzing whole samples in one model rather than, as Bourdieu did, proceeding class-by-class.…”