Development of synovial cysts in the rigid thoracic spine is rare. Additionally, synovial cysts with compression of nerve roots typically cause subacute or chronic radiculopathy. We present a patient who had a new diagnosis of upper thoracic (T1-2) synovial cyst that caused acute paraplegia while hospitalized for therapies and surgical planning. The patient is a 56-year-old male with a history of congestive heart failure secondary to alcoholic cardiomyopathy. He presented with a progressive bilateral lower extremity discoordination, urinary incontinence, and altered perineal sensation. His examination revealed intact strength to bedside assessment, intact rectal tone, but upgoing toes on Babinski testing. Given concern for myelopathy, MRI thoracic spine was obtained and demonstrated large T1-2 synovial cyst causing severe compression with associated T2 signal change within the spinal cord. He underwent expedited cardiac optimization that included resumption of outpatient antihypertensive medications and the addition of a single dose of intravenous diuretic. The patient had subsequent transient hypotension following significant diuresis and developed acute paraplegia in his bilateral lower extremities. Fluids and vasopressors were initiated, and he underwent emergent surgery for decompression and synovial cyst resection. The patient did very well and had normalization of his neurological exam within 24 hours. We present a case of acute paraplegia secondary to hypotension and spinal cord hypoperfusion in a patient with upper thoracic synovial cyst. This is rare pathology with an even more unique presentation. The authors recommend careful perioperative hemodynamic monitoring to help avoid acute worsening in this patient population.