SummaryA ketogenic diet (KD) is a very low-carbohydrate, very high-fat diet proposed to treat obesity and type 2 diabetes. While KD grows in popularity, its effects on metabolic health are understudied. Here we show that, in male and female mice, while KD protects against weight gain and induces weight loss, over long-term, mice develop hyperlipidemia, hepatic steatosis, and severe glucose intolerance. Unlike high fat diet-fed mice, KD mice are not insulin resistant and have low levels of insulin. Hyperglycemic clamp andex vivoGSIS revealed cell-autonomous and whole-body impairments in insulin secretion. Major ER/Golgi stress and disrupted ER-Golgi protein trafficking was indicated by transcriptomic profiling of KD islets and confirmed by electron micrographs showing a dilated Golgi network likely responsible for impaired insulin granule trafficking and secretion. Overall, our results suggest long-term KD leads to multiple aberrations of metabolic parameters that caution its systematic use as a health promoting dietary intervention.