The application of system dynamics modelling to environmental health decision-making and policy - a scoping review

Abstract

BackgroundPolicy and decision-making processes are routinely challenged by the complex and dynamic nature of environmental health problems. System dynamics modelling has demonstrated considerable value across a number of different fields to help decision-makers understand and predict the dynamic behaviour of complex systems in support the development of effective policy actions. In this scoping review we investigate if, and in what contexts, system dynamics modelling is being used to inform policy or decision-making processes related to environmental health.MethodsFour electronic databases and the grey literature were systematically searched to identify studies that intersect the areas environmental health, system dynamics modelling, and decision-making. Studies identified in the initial screening were further screened for their contextual, methodological and application-related relevancy. Studies deemed ‘relevant’ or ‘highly relevant’ according to all three criteria were included in this review. Key themes related to the rationale, impact and limitation of using system dynamics in the context of environmental health decision-making and policy were analysed.ResultsWe identified a limited number of relevant studies (n = 15), two-thirds of which were conducted between 2011 and 2016. The majority of applications occurred in non-health related sectors (n = 9) including transportation, public utilities, water, housing, food, agriculture, and urban and regional planning. Applications were primarily targeted at micro-level (local, community or grassroots) decision-making processes (n = 9), with macro-level (national or international) decision-making to a lesser degree. There was significant heterogeneity in the stated rationales for using system dynamics and the intended impact of the system dynamics model on decision-making processes. A series of user-related, technical and application-related limitations and challenges were identified. None of the reported limitations or challenges appeared unique to the application of system dynamics within the context of environmental health problems, but rather to the use of system dynamics in general.ConclusionsThis review reveals that while system dynamics modelling is increasingly being used to inform decision-making related to environmental health, applications are currently limited. Greater application of system dynamics within this context is needed before its benefits and limitations can be fully understood.

A Proof-of-Concept System Dynamics Simulation Model of the Development of Burnout and Recovery Using Retrospective Case Data

“…Successful prevention and intervention programs involve employees in decision-making and enhance their job control and social support, while the elimination of stressors explains the effectiveness of the prevention and intervention programs [42]. SD has proven to be effective in modeling and analyzing business and healthcare systems characterized by dynamic complexity and uncertainty, as well as experimenting with scenario simulation to design and evaluate interventions for performance management [43,54,57,[66][67][68]. Effective behavioral and cultural change, however, can only be achieved when all crucial elements supporting an effective change are available, including a shared vision, shared mission, clear goals and outcomes, shared responsibility, appropriate skills, supporting environment, and appropriate resources [69].…”

Building community resilience to prevent and mitigate community impact of gun violence: conceptual framework and intervention design

“…Finally, it is possible that the group model building process and will not result in participant openness to challenging their mental models, which would make it challenging to identify novel, multisector, collaborative interventions. 58 59 However, we will engage the community stakeholders for multiple sessions over time in order to build cohesive relationships across sectors and will use the system dynamics model to increase participant openness to new ways of thinking and challenge the phenomenon of policy resistance.…”

Emerging trends and challenges of population-based cardiology

“…The main challenge in studying the role of social factors in cardiovascular epidemiology is an infeasibility of randomized experiments elucidating the multifactorial mechanisms involved in the effects of the social life on health [56]. Despite this, new innovation approaches are under development for the modelling of the sophisticated dynamic systems overcoming this challenge [57]. Besides, there are quite large tine windows between independent and dependent variables and between the action of the social factors and manifestation of their effects, which represents both scientific and political challenges.…”

“…Основным вызовом при исследовании роли социальных факторов в эпидемиологии ССЗ является невозможность проведения рандомизированных экспериментов для изучения сложных многофакторных механизмов, посредством которых социальные факторы влияют на здоровье [56]. Несмотря на это, в настоящее время разрабатываются инновационные подходы к моделированию сложных динамичных систем с целью преодоления этого вызова [57]. Кроме того, существуют весьма длительные временные окна между независимыми и зависимыми переменными, между действием социальных факторов и манифестацией их эффектов, что представляет собой как научный, так и политический вызов.…”