The Discolouration of Human Teeth from Archaeological Contexts: Elemental Analysis of a Black Tooth from a Roman Cranium Recovered from the River Witham, Lincoln, UK

Abstract

A human cranium was recovered from the River Witham, Lincoln, UK, at Stamp End Lock during a police operation in 2002. Although extensive trauma was noted, the skull was not of forensic interest since radiocarbon dating revealed that the individual had lived during the Roman occupation of Lincoln, almost 2,000 years ago. The skull had unusual black “metallic” staining on the occlusal surfaces of the teeth. As this kind of staining is relatively uncommon, it was investigated to determine the possible cause. An individual tooth was subjected to two elemental analyses: inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) and scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray analysis (SEM-EDX). A small sample(n=21)of modern teeth was also analysed for comparison to determine “normal” ranges of certain elements. Analysis of the ancient tooth shows very high levels of manganese (275 µg/g) and iron (1540 µg/g) compared to modern teeth values (1.90 µg/g Mn and 40.81 µg/g Fe). These results were consistent with the black staining arising from iron and manganese infiltrating bone and dental tissue from the depositional environment, and not a consequence of diet, pathological process or cultural practices.

Diagnodent and VistaCam may be unsuitable for the evaluation of dental caries in archeological teeth

“…The assessment of initial stages of dental caries in the form of white or brown discoloration and a gloss or matte surface can be mistaken for nonpathological discoloration or surface texture modification caused by environmental factors or taphonomic changes. They can “mimic” early carious lesions and can be especially problematic (Brown, Dixon, & Birkett, ; Hattab, Qudeimat, & Al‐Rimawi, ; Hillson, ; Watts & Addy, ). Such deceptive effects may be caused by plants growing near surface‐deposited remains, as they may stain the teeth or create a mottled appearance.…”