The Effect of LC-MS Data Preprocessing Methods on the Selection of Plasma Biomarkers in Fed vs. Fasted Rats

Abstract

The metabolic composition of plasma is affected by time passed since the last meal and by individual variation in metabolite clearance rates. Rat plasma in fed and fasted states was analyzed with liquid chromatography quadrupole-time-of-flight mass spectrometry (LC-QTOF) for an untargeted investigation of these metabolite patterns. The dataset was used to investigate the effect of data preprocessing on biomarker selection using three different softwares, MarkerLynxTM, MZmine, XCMS along with a customized preprocessing method that performs binning of m/z channels followed by summation through retention time. Direct comparison of selected features representing the fed or fasted state showed large differences between the softwares. Many false positive markers were obtained from custom data preprocessing compared with dedicated softwares while MarkerLynxTM provided better coverage of markers. However, marker selection was more reliable with the gap filling (or peak finding) algorithms present in MZmine and XCMS. Further identification of the putative markers revealed that many of the differences between the markers selected were due to variations in features representing adducts or daughter ions of the same metabolites or of compounds from the same chemical subclasses, e.g., lyso-phosphatidylcholines (LPCs) and lyso-phosphatidylethanolamines (LPEs). We conclude that despite considerable differences in the performance of the preprocessing tools we could extract the same biological information by any of them. Carnitine, branched-chain amino acids, LPCs and LPEs were identified by all methods as markers of the fed state whereas acetylcarnitine was abundant during fasting in rats.

Advances in mass spectrometry-based metabolomics for investigation of metabolites

“…However, there is no currently available standardized soware/website for MS data processing and analysis. Using different soware, the results will be very different, [153][154][155] which shows that data processing and analysis soware/ websites have a great inuence on data processing. Data processing is a vital part of metabolomics research and each soware/website has its own characteristics.…”

Chemometrics in foodomics: Handling data structures from multiple analytical platforms

“…The main issue is that these software packages do not provide the same results -neither qualitatively (the metabolites found identified with a retention time m/z pair) -nor quantitatively (the relative concentration found in the different samples) [30]. In a recent metabolomics study, several software packages were compared and the shared and unique metabolites were reported [31]. Adding correlation studies on top of such data would further validate the shared metabolites and how the different software packages can extract the same information, as visualized in Fig.…”

LC–MS based global metabolite profiling: the necessity of high data quality

“…It is therefore of utmost importance to assess the quality of the peak picking since it defines the features available for further analysis and it is a huge task to find the correct settings (Brodsky et al 2010). Gürdeniz et al compared the performance of different pre-processing tools, but concluded that the selection of appropriate settings is more important than which software to choose (Gürdeniz et al 2012). Coble and Fraga in a later study focused on the different free softwares and suggests the combination of output from these to achieve high coverage and robust data (Coble and Fraga 2014).…”