Heterotrophic bacteria in the ocean initiate biopolymer degradation using extracellular enzymes that yield low molecular weight hydrolysis products in the environment, or by using a selfish uptake mechanism that retains the hydrolysate for the enzyme‐producing cell. The mechanism used affects the availability of hydrolysis products to other bacteria, and thus also potentially the composition and activity of the community. In marine systems, these two mechanisms of substrate processing have been studied in the water column, but to date, have not been investigated in sediments. In surface sediments from an Arctic fjord of Svalbard, we investigated mechanisms of biopolymer hydrolysis using four polysaccharides and mucin, a glycoprotein. Extracellular hydrolysis of all biopolymers was rapid. Moreover, rapid degradation of mucin suggests that it may be a key substrate for benthic microbes. Although selfish uptake is common in ocean waters, only a small fraction (0.5%–2%) of microbes adhering to sediments used this mechanism. Selfish uptake was carried out primarily by Planctomycetota and Verrucomicrobiota. The overall dominance of extracellular hydrolysis in sediments, however, suggests that the bulk of biopolymer processing is carried out by a benthic community relying on the sharing of enzymatic capabilities and scavenging of public goods.